%PDF-1.4
%
1 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 2 0 R
/Metadata 3 0 R
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/CreationDate (09-21-2009)
/Author (exs)
/Producer (eCopy, Inc)
/Creator (eCopy, Inc)
/ModDate (09-21-2009)
>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/Count 38
/Type /Pages
/Kids [5 0 R 6 0 R 7 0 R 8 0 R 9 0 R 10 0 R 11 0 R 12 0 R 13 0 R 14 0 R
15 0 R 16 0 R 17 0 R 18 0 R 19 0 R 20 0 R 21 0 R 22 0 R 23 0 R 24 0 R
25 0 R 26 0 R 27 0 R 28 0 R 29 0 R 30 0 R 31 0 R 32 0 R 33 0 R 34 0 R
35 0 R 36 0 R 37 0 R 38 0 R 39 0 R 40 0 R 41 0 R 42 0 R]
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/Type /Metadata
/Length 43 0 R
/Subtype /XML
>>
stream
application/pdf
exs
eCopy, Inc
2009-09-21T17:18:15-07:00
2009-09-21T17:18:15-07:00
2009-09-21T17:18:15-07:00
eCopy, Inc
uuid:f98c40f5-5a82-43af-8f34-b24787c93045
uuid:1495c4db-d549-4fe5-af81-251b536463b6
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [44 0 R 45 0 R 46 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 47 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [48 0 R 49 0 R 50 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 51 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [52 0 R 53 0 R 54 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 55 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [56 0 R 57 0 R 58 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 59 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [60 0 R 61 0 R 62 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 63 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [64 0 R 65 0 R 66 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 67 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [68 0 R 69 0 R 70 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 71 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [72 0 R 73 0 R 74 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 75 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [76 0 R 77 0 R 78 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 79 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [80 0 R 81 0 R 82 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 83 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [84 0 R 85 0 R 86 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 87 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [88 0 R 89 0 R 90 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 91 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [92 0 R 93 0 R 94 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 95 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [96 0 R 97 0 R 98 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 99 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [100 0 R 101 0 R 102 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 103 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [104 0 R 105 0 R 106 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 107 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [108 0 R 109 0 R 110 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 111 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [112 0 R 113 0 R 114 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 115 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [116 0 R 117 0 R 118 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 119 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [120 0 R 121 0 R 122 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 123 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [124 0 R 125 0 R 126 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 127 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [128 0 R 129 0 R 130 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 131 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [132 0 R 133 0 R 134 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 135 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [136 0 R 137 0 R 138 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 139 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [140 0 R 141 0 R 142 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 143 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [144 0 R 145 0 R 146 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 147 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [148 0 R 149 0 R 150 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 151 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [152 0 R 153 0 R 154 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 155 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [156 0 R 157 0 R 158 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 159 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [160 0 R 161 0 R 162 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 163 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [164 0 R 165 0 R 166 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 167 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [168 0 R 169 0 R 170 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 171 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [172 0 R 173 0 R 174 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 175 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [176 0 R 177 0 R 178 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 179 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [180 0 R 181 0 R 182 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 183 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [184 0 R 185 0 R 186 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 187 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [188 0 R 189 0 R 190 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 191 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/eCpyResolution 300
/Contents [192 0 R 193 0 R 194 0 R]
/Parent 2 0 R
/Resources 195 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0
/Annots []
>>
endobj
43 0 obj
3534
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 196 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/Length 197 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im7 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F8 20.82 Tf
100 Tz
250.80 471.84 TD
(EXHIBIT 1) Tj
/F8 5.00 Tf
12.72 -23.28 TD
(TO ) Tj
/F8 20.99 Tf
34.08 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F8 21.17 Tf
-230.40 -24.24 TD
(DECLARATION OF JAMES G. GILLILAND, JR. IN) Tj
/F8 21.18 Tf
22.08 -23.04 TD
(SUPPORT OF APPLE INC.'S OPPOSITION TO) Tj
/F8 21.09 Tf
17.04 -22.56 TD
(PSYSTAR CORPORATION'S MOTION TO) Tj
/F8 21.18 Tf
-8.40 -23.28 TD
(STRIKE THE DECLARATION OF JACQUES) Tj
/F8 20.80 Tf
51.84 -23.04 TD
(VIDRINE AND FOR SANCTIONS) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 198 0 R
>>
stream
x%0F<ſEL[\JD
*z6!xC*Б*wpk0bWpbkrQS `?7)ߒe$8eh纏-F@ ;
endstream
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/XObject 199 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 200 0 R
>>
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 201 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/Length 202 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im12 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F13 11.00 Tf
100 Tz
409.44 703.44 TD
(Pages 1 - 37) Tj
/F13 11.27 Tf
-186.96 -25.92 TD
(UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT) Tj
/F13 11.32 Tf
-10.08 -24.72 TD
(NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA) Tj
/F13 11.56 Tf
-19.68 -25.20 TD
(BEFORE THE HONORALE WILLIAM H. ALSUP) Tj
/F13 11.28 Tf
-88.80 -25.20 TD
(APPLE INC., a California) Tj
/F14 16.05 Tf
1.20 -12.72 TD
(corporation,) Tj
/F14 18.17 Tf
88.32 -24.48 TD
(Plaintiff,) Tj
/F14 11.94 Tf
-75.36 -25.20 TD
(VS.) Tj
/F13 11.29 Tf
244.32 1.20 TD
(No. C 08-3251 WHA) Tj
/F13 11.25 Tf
-257.04 -25.92 TD
(PSYSTAR CORPORATION, a Florida) Tj
/F13 11.08 Tf
0.00 -12.48 TD
(corporation, and DOES 1-10,) Tj
/F14 16.60 Tf
0.48 -12.24 TD
(inclusive,) Tj
/F14 14.94 Tf
87.60 -24.72 TD
(Defendants.) Tj
/F13 11.22 Tf
170.16 13.20 TD
(San Francisco, California) Tj
/F14 15.26 Tf
0.00 -12.48 TD
(Friday) Tj
/F13 11.11 Tf
0.24 -12.24 TD
(September 4, 2009) Tj
/F13 11.25 Tf
-129.60 -50.16 TD
(TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS) Tj
/F14 11.91 Tf
-129.12 -25.44 TD
(APPEARACES:) Tj
/F13 10.97 Tf
0.72 -24.72 TD
(For Plaintiff:) Tj
/F13 11.28 Tf
162.72 0.72 TD
(TOWNSEND AND TOWNSEND AND CREW LLP) Tj
/F13 11.27 Tf
0.24 -12.48 TD
(Two Embarcadero Center - 8th Floor) Tj
/F13 11.53 Tf
0.24 -12.48 TD
(San Francisco, California 94111-3834) Tj
/F13 12.28 Tf
-34.32 -12.48 TD
(BY: JAMS G. GILLILAN, JR., ESQUIRE) Tj
/F13 11.30 Tf
33.60 -12.48 TD
(MEGAN M. CHUNG, ESQUIRE) Tj
/F15 11.94 Tf
0.24 -12.24 TD
(MEHRNAZ BOROUM SMITH, ESQUIRE) Tj
/F13 11.00 Tf
-162.24 -25.68 TD
(For Defendant:) Tj
/F14 12.58 Tf
162.96 0.72 TD
(CAMRA & SIBLEY, LLP) Tj
/F13 11.30 Tf
0.00 -12.48 TD
(2339 University Boulevard) Tj
/F13 11.80 Tf
-.24 -12.48 TD
(Houston, Texas 77005) Tj
/F13 12.19 Tf
-34.08 -12.48 TD
(BY: KIWI ALEJANRO DANAO CAMRA, ESQUIRE) Tj
/F15 13.53 Tf
-128.16 -100.56 TD
(Reported By:) Tj
/F14 9.65 Tf
109.20 -1.44 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Suf\(f:vanJ CSCJ #5812) Tj
/F14 10.58 Tf
0.24 -10.80 TD
(Ojficiaf 1?porter - 'U.s istrict Court .) Tj
/F14 10.23 Tf
24.96 -38.40 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff SuffivanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F13 8.11 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F13 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 203 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3.k3l-`D%<%=h<;^ ؒa{Gh^ɭ0װ\ϐo2qo`U,ɧK+JH% ;|
endstream
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/XObject 204 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 205 0 R
>>
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 206 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/Length 207 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im19 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F20 9.60 Tf
100 Tz
509.76 742.80 TD
(2) Tj
-423.84 -40.56 TD
(1) Tj
/F20 20.52 Tf
161.28 0.24 TD
(PROCEEDINGS) Tj
/F21 11.68 Tf
-161.52 -25.20 TD
(2 SEPTEMBER 4, 2009) Tj
/F22 12.41 Tf
365.28 0.72 TD
(10: 05 A.M) Tj
/F20 8.64 Tf
-365.04 -25.92 TD
(3) Tj
/F20 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(4) Tj
/F21 11.49 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(THE CLERK: Calling civil 08-3251, Apple versus) Tj
/F21 11.76 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(5 Psystar.) Tj
/F21 13.42 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 Counsel, please state your appearance for the record.) Tj
/F21 13.54 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 Would you like everyone to come to the microphone,) Tj
/F21 11.78 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(8 Your Honor?) Tj
/F20 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9) Tj
/F22 12.59 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Yes.) Tj
/F20 11.28 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(10) Tj
/F22 13.92 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE CLERK: Counsel, please come to the microphone.) Tj
/F20 11.52 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(11) Tj
/F20 14.72 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Good morning, Your Honor.) Tj
/F21 13.53 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(12 Jim Gilliland and Mehrnaz Smith and Megan Chung for) Tj
/F21 11.48 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 the plaintiff Apple.) Tj
/F20 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.48 TD
(14) Tj
/F22 12.85 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Good morning.) Tj
/F20 11.28 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(15) Tj
/F20 14.41 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Good morning, Your Honor.) Tj
/F20 11.28 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F21 11.20 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(Kiwi Camara for the defendant Psystar Corporation.) Tj
/F20 11.28 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F22 13.54 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Everyone have a seat.) Tj
/F20 11.28 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F21 11.47 Tf
94.08 0.24 TD
(I read most of this material. Have you resolved all) Tj
/F20 17.92 Tf
-94.08 -25.20 TD
(19 of your problems? First, let me ask this) Tj
/F20 11.52 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F20 15.89 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(MR. CARA: Half of them, Your Honor.) Tj
/F20 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(21) Tj
/F21 11.54 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: What half have you resolved?) Tj
/F20 11.52 Tf
-93.84 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F22 14.53 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: We have resolved parts two and three of) Tj
/F22 16.87 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(23 the briefing.) Tj
/F22 17.84 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 We have resolved the dispute about Mr. Schiller IS) Tj
/F21 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25 testimony concerning whether he had compared Apple products to) Tj
/F22 10.85 Tf
160.32 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSufvanJ CSCF ~C~) Tj
/F21 7.65 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offiaf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F21 7.86 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 208 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;.k3L-`D%<%=h`K ڒqe4VW\kػ\ϐo2&R:'.y-|1+J;
endstream
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/XObject 209 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 210 0 R
>>
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 211 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/Length 212 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im26 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F27 8.64 Tf
100 Tz
509.04 742.56 TD
(3) Tj
/F28 11.52 Tf
-423.84 -40.80 TD
(1 Psystar products.) Tj
/F28 13.80 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 And we've resolved the issue about the missing) Tj
/F28 5.00 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 affidavit and about whether or not that was relied on ) Tj
/F28 10.89 Tf
385.20 0.96 TD
(in one of) Tj
/F28 11.52 Tf
-385.44 -25.92 TD
(4 the expert reports.) Tj
/F28 13.78 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 So the outstanding issues are the testimony of) Tj
/F28 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 Jacques Vidrine and the document production.) Tj
/F27 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7) Tj
/F28 11.48 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: It is my understanding, Your Honor, that) Tj
/F28 11.35 Tf
-85.92 -25.20 TD
(8 Psystar is withdrawing their motions on sections two and three.) Tj
/F27 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9) Tj
/F27 15.51 Tf
85.92 0.48 TD
(MR. CARA: We are, Your Honor.) Tj
/F27 11.28 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(10) Tj
/F28 11.56 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(THE COURT: Well, all right.) Tj
/F27 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(11) Tj
/F28 11.05 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(Now, I need to - - reading your material here, I want) Tj
/F28 11.42 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(12 to - - something dawned on me. I am conducting a wedding in) Tj
/F29 15.54 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(13 October. The wedding is one of my former law clerks. Not) Tj
/F27 17.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 Ms. Chung. She is already married. It i S a different law clerk) Tj
/F28 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 from about five years ago. And she is marrying Tom --) Tj
/F27 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F29 13.99 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: LaPerle.) Tj
/F27 11.28 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(17) Tj
/F28 11.62 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: -- LaPerle.) Tj
/F27 11.28 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F28 11.24 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(So in October I will be standing in front of Thomas) Tj
/F27 11.52 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F27 15.21 Tf
25.44 0.00 TD
(LaPerle,) Tj
/F27 11.57 Tf
60.72 0.24 TD
(who) Tj
/F27 13.69 Tf
28.32 0.00 TD
(I) Tj
/F28 10.95 Tf
13.44 -.24 TD
(see here) Tj
/F27 17.28 Tf
60.96 0.24 TD
(is) Tj
/F27 11.71 Tf
19.44 0.00 TD
(now) Tj
/F28 10.84 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(a witness.) Tj
/F27 11.76 Tf
-236.16 -25.20 TD
(20) Tj
/F27 10.10 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F27 11.38 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F27 15.87 Tf
61.20 0.00 TD
(Congratulations,) Tj
/F28 10.91 Tf
115.20 0.48 TD
(Your Honor.) Tj
/F27 12.00 Tf
-297.12 -25.68 TD
(21) Tj
/F28 11.20 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(We have no) Tj
/F27 14.40 Tf
74.64 0.24 TD
(problem.) Tj
/F27 11.76 Tf
-168.00 -25.44 TD
(22) Tj
/F28 10.88 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT:) Tj
/F27 15.22 Tf
81.12 0.24 TD
(All) Tj
/F27 17.62 Tf
27.84 0.00 TD
(right.) Tj
/F27 11.82 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(So) Tj
/F28 11.15 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(that you) Tj
/F27 13.87 Tf
60.48 0.24 TD
(waive) Tj
/F27 13.80 Tf
41.04 0.00 TD
(any) Tj
/F27 11.28 Tf
-378.72 -25.68 TD
(23) Tj
/F27 16.95 Tf
25.92 -.24 TD
(conflict?) Tj
/F27 11.52 Tf
-25.92 -24.72 TD
(24) Tj
/F28 11.77 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: We waive any conflict arising out of) Tj
/F29 15.70 Tf
-93.12 -25.44 TD
(25 your presiding.) Tj
/F29 10.93 Tf
160.08 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\(Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~C~) Tj
/F28 8.11 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F27 10.56 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 213 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 216 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/Length 217 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im33 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F34 9.12 Tf
100 Tz
509.28 741.60 TD
(4) Tj
/F34 10.08 Tf
-423.60 -40.08 TD
(1) Tj
-.48 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F34 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F34 10.08 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F34 9.60 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F34 16.65 Tf
19.44 0.24 TD
(issues.) Tj
/F34 9.60 Tf
-19.44 -25.20 TD
(6) Tj
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F35 12.92 Tf
86.40 174.48 TD
(THE COURT: How about Apple?) Tj
/F36 11.47 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We have no issues, Your Honor.) Tj
/F34 13.05 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(THE COURT: What?) Tj
/F36 11.79 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We waive any conflict. We have no) Tj
/F35 14.69 Tf
0.48 -49.68 TD
(THE COURT: Fine. Tha tIs not an issue then.) Tj
/F34 18.00 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(Okay. So tell me, what is the first issue?) Tj
/F36 11.77 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, the first issue is the) Tj
/F36 11.59 Tf
-85.92 -24.96 TD
(9 testimony of Jacques Vidrine. Mr. Vidrine is the head of OS X) Tj
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 security. He was not disclosed either in Apple's initial) Tj
/F36 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 disclosures or in any supplementation to any of those) Tj
/F34 17.53 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 disclosures.) Tj
/F34 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F36 11.71 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Wait a minute. Disclosures only require) Tj
/F35 15.53 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(14 them to disclose who they are going to rely on.) Tj
/F34 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
/F35 15.20 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: This is true.) Tj
/F34 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F36 10.64 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(He wasn i t disclosed in response to any - - in any) Tj
/F36 11.43 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(17 form, in response to any question about who had conducted) Tj
/F36 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 investigation into whether Psystar circumvented Apple's) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 technological protection measures.) Tj
/F34 20.79 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 He was not disclosed in response to any --) Tj
/F34 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21) Tj
/F36 11.89 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Wait. You are using the word) Tj
/F35 15.71 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(22 "disclosure," and that bothers me. You i ve got to use the right) Tj
/F35 15.19 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 terminology here.) Tj
/F34 19.23 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 Rule 26 \(a\) says, "The name and, if known, address and) Tj
/F36 11.42 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(25 telephone number of each individual likely to have discoverable) Tj
/F35 9.41 Tf
159.84 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF CJCF C~) Tj
/F34 11.29 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F36 7.80 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 218 0 R
>>
stream
x%90~NK(gUDm8Q!b=?(CI$b0ώwԒq2
4VlW\/|\؍g8d[n8j#Se-JD% <
endstream
endobj
63 0 obj
<<
/XObject 219 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 220 0 R
>>
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 221 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/Length 222 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im40 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F41 9.60 Tf
100 Tz
508.56 741.60 TD
(5) Tj
/F42 11.41 Tf
-424.32 -40.80 TD
(1 information that the disclosing party may use to support its) Tj
/F42 11.56 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 claims or defenses.") Tj
/F42 11.19 Tf
169.92 0.24 TD
("May use to support its claims or) Tj
/F42 11.61 Tf
-169.68 -25.20 TD
(3 defenses." It does not have to disclose witnesses that are) Tj
/F42 11.54 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 going to help you.) Tj
/F42 13.41 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 Now, if you had propounded an interrogatory and said,) Tj
/F42 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 "Name each person who has done X, Y, or Z," and Mr. Vidrine fit) Tj
/F42 11.37 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 within that, they would have to tell you that in the answer.) Tj
/F41 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(8) Tj
/F42 11.53 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(But your motion -- I read it. Your motion is) Tj
/F42 11.59 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(9 directed at a disclosure violation. You say, "Apple failed to) Tj
/F42 11.45 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 disclose by agreeing in its initial disclosures or in any) Tj
/F41 16.97 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 supplement to those disclosures.") Tj
/F43 19.18 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(12 Well, if that i s true, then the answer is they can't) Tj
/F42 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 rely on Vidrine, period, for any purpose.) Tj
/F41 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14) Tj
/F41 14.34 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Okay, Your Honor.) Tj
/F41 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(15) Tj
/F42 11.48 Tf
93.36 0.48 TD
(THE COURT: Are you planning on relying on Vidrine as) Tj
/F42 11.41 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(16 a witness on summary judgment and/or at trial, Ms. Chung?) Tj
/F41 21.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 If you are, you are out of luck unless you get relief) Tj
/F41 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F42 11.07 Tf
26.16 0.00 TD
(from your) Tj
/F41 16.97 Tf
67.20 0.24 TD
(default.) Tj
/F41 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(19) Tj
/F41 10.76 Tf
92.88 0.48 TD
(MS.) Tj
/F41 9.96 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(CHUNG:) Tj
/F42 10.87 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(Your Honor,) Tj
/F41 10.71 Tf
81.60 0.24 TD
(we) Tj
/F41 13.86 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(have) Tj
/F41 15.52 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F41 16.21 Tf
27.60 0.24 TD
(issue) Tj
/F41 14.99 Tf
40.08 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F41 15.32 Tf
20.64 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F41 12.00 Tf
-399.84 -25.92 TD
(20) Tj
/F41 16.40 Tf
25.68 0.24 TD
(notice) Tj
/F41 14.41 Tf
48.00 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F41 14.16 Tf
19.68 0.00 TD
(pendency) Tj
/F41 16.05 Tf
62.16 0.24 TD
(in) Tj
/F41 16.24 Tf
19.92 0.00 TD
(other) Tj
/F41 16.21 Tf
41.28 0.00 TD
(action) Tj
/F41 15.43 Tf
47.76 0.24 TD
(in) Tj
/F41 16.12 Tf
19.92 0.00 TD
(Florida) Tj
/F41 15.59 Tf
54.48 0.24 TD
(case.) Tj
/F42 11.33 Tf
46.56 0.00 TD
(And my) Tj
/F41 12.24 Tf
-385.44 -25.68 TD
(21) Tj
/F41 15.16 Tf
26.40 0.00 TD
(response) Tj
/F41 16.05 Tf
60.96 0.00 TD
(to) Tj
/F42 11.02 Tf
20.40 0.24 TD
(that will) Tj
/F42 11.17 Tf
67.68 0.00 TD
(depend on that) Tj
/F41 16.54 Tf
102.72 0.48 TD
(issue.) Tj
/F41 11.76 Tf
-277.92 -25.68 TD
(22) Tj
/F41 13.90 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(Because) Tj
/F41 14.77 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(our) Tj
/F41 16.84 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(position) Tj
/F41 12.35 Tf
61.44 0.24 TD
(was) Tj
/F42 11.24 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(that we had) Tj
/F42 11.14 Tf
81.60 0.24 TD
(an outstanding) Tj
/F42 11.63 Tf
-345.60 -25.92 TD
(23 discovery response to Psystar. And we specifically asked them) Tj
/F42 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 if they -- and we asked them with meet and confer with the) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 prior counsel for Psystar about R&D development, as well as any) Tj
/F42 7.00 Tf
160.08 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF CJCF CCJCJ) Tj
/F41 11.29 Tf
11.28 -10.80 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F42 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
66 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 223 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ƚ0>7P{oK)u74ѕ`!KxJz6![AbC
Gid\'r OϷd2qAf6btT=l
endstream
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/XObject 224 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 225 0 R
>>
endobj
68 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 226 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/Length 227 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im47 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F48 9.12 Tf
100 Tz
510.00 741.12 TD
(6) Tj
/F49 11.40 Tf
-424.32 -40.32 TD
(1 new products that are coming into the case.) Tj
/F48 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F49 11.81 Tf
86.88 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Wait a minute. On the present) Tj
/F49 11.93 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(3 pleadings) Tj
/F48 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F48 13.57 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes.) Tj
/F48 9.60 Tf
-86.40 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F49 11.42 Tf
86.88 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Forget that case in Florida for a moment.) Tj
/F48 9.12 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F48 13.39 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Okay.) Tj
/F48 9.60 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(7) Tj
/F49 10.83 Tf
86.88 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: I f you didn i t disclose Vidrine, you are) Tj
/F48 17.92 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(8 not going to be allowed to use him. That's just the way it is.) Tj
/F49 13.54 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9 Now, a substantial justification for using him would) Tj
/F49 11.35 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 be if at the last minute some new issue came out of left field,) Tj
/F49 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 and they brought it up on the other side such that you were) Tj
/F49 11.06 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(12 surprised, and now you i ve got to enlarge the group of witnesses) Tj
/F48 17.08 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 you want to rely on.) Tj
/F48 20.97 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 I would allow you, for that kind of substantial) Tj
/F49 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 justification, to submit a new supplement to your initial) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 disclosures, even at this late hour, if it really was that) Tj
/F48 17.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 scenario.) Tj
/F50 17.59 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(18 But 11m not going to do it because there i s some) Tj
/F49 11.56 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 lawsuit in Florida. That has nothing to do with my lawsuit.) Tj
/F49 14.63 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 MS. CHUNG: I understand, Your Honor.) Tj
/F49 13.80 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 THE COURT: So the normal answer to this problem is) Tj
/F49 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 they didn't have to disclose Vidrine. But the penalty for not) Tj
/F49 10.86 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23 doing it is they can i t use him.) Tj
/F48 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F50 13.08 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We understand.) Tj
/F48 12.00 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(25) Tj
/F49 11.26 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: So that's - - that's) Tj
/F50 10.54 Tf
66.48 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~ C~) Tj
/F48 11.38 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offa\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F49 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
70 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 228 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;,k3L-`D%<=h`s_@%"E4ԯ\kػ\ϐo2&c҅ub9N>]
[rW)U=
endstream
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/XObject 229 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 230 0 R
>>
endobj
72 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 231 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/Length 232 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im54 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F55 9.12 Tf
100 Tz
510.24 740.88 TD
(7) Tj
/F55 9.60 Tf
-424.08 -40.32 TD
(1) Tj
/F56 11.48 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We do believe there was new issues raised) Tj
/F56 11.61 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(2 by counsel. But if you give me one moment, i will --) Tj
/F55 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F56 11.58 Tf
87.12 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right.) Tj
/F55 10.08 Tf
-87.36 -25.20 TD
(4) Tj
/F55 13.69 Tf
90.00 -.96 TD
(\(Pause\)) Tj
/F55 9.60 Tf
-89.52 -24.00 TD
(5) Tj
/F56 11.53 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Your Honor, Apple will not use) Tj
/F56 11.43 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(6 Mr. Vidrine either for trial or for purposes of summary) Tj
/F56 11.71 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7 judgment.) Tj
/F55 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F56 11.52 Tf
86.88 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Any of your experts who ar going to be) Tj
/F55 9.60 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(9) Tj
/F55 16.61 Tf
18.96 0.00 TD
(relying) Tj
/F56 10.80 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(on him?) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
-80.16 -24.96 TD
(10) Tj
/F55 10.76 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MS.) Tj
/F55 9.90 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(CHUNG:) Tj
/F55 12.07 Tf
53.52 0.00 TD
(No.) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
-174.00 -24.96 TD
(11) Tj
/F55 10.00 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(THE) Tj
/F55 10.34 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F57 12.01 Tf
54.00 0.24 TD
(That i s) Tj
/F55 13.73 Tf
47.76 -.24 TD
(an) Tj
/F55 17.05 Tf
21.12 0.24 TD
(indirect) Tj
/F55 12.78 Tf
59.76 0.00 TD
(way.) Tj
/F55 11.28 Tf
-303.12 -24.96 TD
(12) Tj
/F55 15.08 Tf
94.08 0.00 TD
(So Vidrine) Tj
/F55 17.28 Tf
74.40 0.24 TD
(is) Tj
/F55 15.03 Tf
19.68 -.24 TD
(out) Tj
/F55 14.70 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F55 14.54 Tf
20.16 0.24 TD
(your) Tj
/F55 14.92 Tf
34.56 0.00 TD
(case) Tj
/F55 17.29 Tf
33.84 0.00 TD
(totally?) Tj
/F55 11.04 Tf
-304.08 -25.20 TD
(13) Tj
/F55 10.62 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(MS.) Tj
/F55 9.83 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(CHUNG:) Tj
/F55 13.56 Tf
53.52 0.00 TD
(Yes.) Tj
/F55 11.28 Tf
-174.24 -24.96 TD
(14) Tj
/F55 10.13 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F55 10.28 Tf
27.12 -.24 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F55 14.15 Tf
53.76 0.24 TD
(That) Tj
34.32 0.00 TD
(ends) Tj
/F55 15.52 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F55 13.72 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(Rule) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
34.08 0.24 TD
(26) Tj
/F55 14.40 Tf
19.44 0.00 TD
(problem.) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
-323.52 -25.20 TD
(15) Tj
/F55 9.96 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F55 11.32 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F55 19.25 Tf
61.20 0.24 TD
(It) Tj
/F55 14.87 Tf
19.92 -.24 TD
(does,) Tj
/F55 13.08 Tf
40.80 0.24 TD
(Your) Tj
/F55 13.44 Tf
34.08 0.00 TD
(Honor.) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
-276.72 -25.20 TD
(16) Tj
/F55 10.00 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F55 10.28 Tf
26.88 -.24 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F55 15.41 Tf
53.28 0.24 TD
(All) Tj
/F55 17.73 Tf
28.08 0.00 TD
(right.) Tj
/F55 11.82 Tf
54.72 0.00 TD
(So) Tj
/F56 11.26 Tf
19.68 0.00 TD
(now how) Tj
/F55 14.59 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(about) Tj
/F55 15.52 Tf
40.80 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F55 13.45 Tf
26.88 0.24 TD
(document) Tj
/F55 11.28 Tf
-398.40 -25.44 TD
(17) Tj
/F55 16.04 Tf
25.92 0.00 TD
(request) Tj
/F55 13.92 Tf
54.00 0.24 TD
(problem?) Tj
/F55 11.28 Tf
-79.92 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F55 10.10 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F55 11.25 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F56 10.95 Tf
60.24 0.00 TD
(Your Honor,) Tj
/F56 11.05 Tf
82.56 0.00 TD
(the documents) Tj
/F56 11.29 Tf
94.08 0.48 TD
(have been) Tj
/F56 11.37 Tf
-357.60 -25.44 TD
(19 produced by Apple as a continuous sequence of digitized files.) Tj
/F55 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F56 11.76 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: I read that. But they said that your) Tj
/F56 11.56 Tf
-93.84 -24.96 TD
(21 predecessors agreed to that. And you have been even worse,) Tj
/F55 17.58 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 they say.) Tj
/F55 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23) Tj
/F55 16.41 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(MR. CARA: There is no evidence of the agreement) Tj
/F56 11.60 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(24 either that Apple has produced in writing. There is no e-mail) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 that manifests that agreement. There is no signed document of) Tj
/F55 10.37 Tf
159.84 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F56 8.11 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F56 7.86 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 233 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0W]ZX7:D*>d
endstream
endobj
75 0 obj
<<
/XObject 234 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 235 0 R
>>
endobj
76 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 236 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
77 0 obj
<<
/Length 237 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im61 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F62 8.64 Tf
100 Tz
509.28 740.88 TD
(8) Tj
/F63 11.40 Tf
-424.08 -40.56 TD
(1 any kind that manifests that agreement.) Tj
/F63 13.57 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 We have conferred with prior counsel twice today,) Tj
/F63 11.36 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(3 once before the meet and confer with Apple, and once after.) Tj
/F63 11.40 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 Before the meet and confer, we asked if there was any agreement) Tj
/F63 11.42 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 that the documents be produced other than in the ordinary) Tj
/F63 11.58 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 manner in which they are kept. Former counsel said there was) Tj
/F63 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7 no such agreement.) Tj
/F63 13.49 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 At the meet and confer, Apple told us they reached an) Tj
/F63 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 oral agreement with prior counsel that the documents would be) Tj
-6.72 -24.96 TD
(10 produced, clumped by source or custodian of the document, but) Tj
/F63 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 with no further information about what the source was or the) Tj
/F63 11.36 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 internal organization of the documents from that source.) Tj
/F64 17.87 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(13 We took that information and again asked former) Tj
/F63 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 counsel whether there was any such agreement. And I have) Tj
/F63 11.24 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(15 e-mail from five minutes ago, from" former counsel, saying that) Tj
/F63 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 there was no such agreement.) Tj
/F63 13.86 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 And so the manner in which the documents are) Tj
/F62 16.49 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 produced, it i S a continuous stream, which gives us no) Tj
/F62 16.53 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 information about how each of the individuals - - and Apple) Tj
/F63 11.46 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 stores documents by individuals rather than centrally) Tj
/F63 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21 organized those documents, nothing at all, other than the page) Tj
/F63 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 by page electronic files themselves.) Tj
/F62 11.52 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F62 13.57 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Ms. Chung.) Tj
/F62 11.76 Tf
-93.84 -25.20 TD
(24) Tj
/F63 11.55 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Your Honor, we attended that meet and) Tj
/F64 15.98 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(25 confer with opposing counsel. So did Mr. Gilliland,) Tj
/F63 6.99 Tf
160.08 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF CJCF CCJCJ) Tj
/F63 7.66 Tf
10.80 -10.80 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F63 7.89 Tf
46.08 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
78 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 238 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0W]
ZX7:D*>
endstream
endobj
79 0 obj
<<
/XObject 239 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 240 0 R
>>
endobj
80 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 241 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
81 0 obj
<<
/Length 242 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im68 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F69 9.12 Tf
100 Tz
509.04 741.12 TD
(9) Tj
/F70 11.47 Tf
-423.84 -40.80 TD
(1 Ms. Boroumand Smith") Tj
/F70 13.59 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 And we did have that agreement that we will not be) Tj
/F70 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 providing source information, including metadata which contains) Tj
/F70 11.41 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 the folder structure or file path information that Mr. Camara) Tj
/F70 11.43 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 seeks now at this late hour.) Tj
/F69 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(6) Tj
/F70 11.69 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Wait a minute. When were these documents) Tj
/F70 11.82 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(7 produced?) Tj
/F69 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F71 13.31 Tf
86.16 0.48 TD
(MS. CHUNG: These documents have been produced by) Tj
/F70 11.41 Tf
-85.92 -25.20 TD
(9 Psystar since December of 2008, without any of the folder) Tj
/F70 11.37 Tf
-6.72 -24.96 TD
(10 structure, and since January of 2009, from Apple.) Tj
/F69 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11) Tj
/F70 11.49 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: If this violated something, why didn't) Tj
/F70 11.48 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(12 someone raise it before now?) Tj
/F69 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F70 11.44 Tf
92.88 0.48 TD
(MS. CHUNG: That is exactly our point, Your Honor.) Tj
/F70 11.36 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(14 We never raised it because we knew that this agreement existed.) Tj
/F69 20.27 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 And Psystar has raised other issues with myself) Tj
/F70 5.00 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(16 directly to meet and confer about document production, ) Tj
/F69 15.22 Tf
398.16 0.96 TD
(but) Tj
/F69 17.98 Tf
-398.16 -25.92 TD
(17 never raised this issue.) Tj
/F69 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18) Tj
/F70 11.52 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: If this was a violation of something, why) Tj
/F70 11.42 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(19 didn't your prior counsel say something about it?) Tj
/F69 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F71 15.05 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: I don't know that, Your Honor. 11m not) Tj
/F70 11.44 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(21 aware of what caused many of the decisions that were made by) Tj
/F70 11.58 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 prior counsel.) Tj
/F70 13.54 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(23 i will say that when we came into the case, we have) Tj
/F69 16.84 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 supplemented all of our productions, with possibly one) Tj
/F70 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 exception, so that they are organized by document requests.) Tj
/F70 6.99 Tf
159.84 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF CJCF CCJCJ) Tj
/F70 8.12 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F70 7.86 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
82 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 243 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;k3L-`D%<%=h`K!ڒYh^ɯ0װwK1n?C%&R:'. clዹ^iTY
endstream
endobj
83 0 obj
<<
/XObject 244 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 245 0 R
>>
endobj
84 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 246 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
85 0 obj
<<
/Length 247 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im75 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F76 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
502.08 740.88 TD
(10) Tj
/F76 9.12 Tf
-416.64 -40.80 TD
(1) Tj
/F77 14.96 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(So Psystar is now picking one of the two al ternati ves) Tj
/F78 11.40 Tf
-87.12 -24.96 TD
(2 under the rule. To the extent Apple has a complaint - - and) Tj
/F78 11.37 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 they havenlt raised one yet, but to the extent they do, we will) Tj
/F78 11.38 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 correct the rest of our production to be responsive by document) Tj
/F78 11.72 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 request.) Tj
/F78 13.73 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 The delay may be evidence or not evidence of an) Tj
/F78 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7 agreement, but we think we are entitled to get the documents) Tj
/F78 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 produced correctly, or to get an appropriate sanction for our) Tj
/F78 5.00 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 time in organizing those documents if ) Tj
/F76 19.07 Tf
276.48 0.72 TD
(there is in fact --) Tj
/F76 11.28 Tf
-283.20 -25.68 TD
(10) Tj
/F78 11.76 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(THE COURT: Both sides did it. Sounds like both) Tj
/F78 11.37 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(11 sides did it this way, so there was an agreement.) Tj
/F77 18.43 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12 Isn i t that evidence of an agreement, that it was) Tj
/F78 11.21 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 unobjected to for all this time? It i S a course of conduct) Tj
/F78 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 unobj ected to. That tends to show there was an agreement to do) Tj
/F78 11.55 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(15 it this way.) Tj
/F76 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F77 15.26 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: It does, Your Honor. But there are) Tj
/F78 11.39 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(17 agreements in writing about a whole variety of other far less) Tj
/F77 16.06 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 important things than this.) Tj
/F77 18.02 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(19 For example, e-mail service is documented in writing.) Tj
/F78 11.44 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(20 The fact that things will appear in TIF files appears in) Tj
/F77 16.91 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(21 writing.) Tj
/F77 17.67 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 We have consulted prior counsel, and theylve denied) Tj
/F78 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 that there is any such agreement.) Tj
/F76 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F78 11.50 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(We have no evidence of such an agreement. Apple has) Tj
/F78 11.41 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(25 produced no evidence of such an agreement.) Tj
/F77 9.44 Tf
160.08 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff SuffivanJ CSCF CJCF C~) Tj
/F78 7.86 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offiaf CRorter - VS. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F78 7.80 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
86 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 248 0 R
>>
stream
x%ȹ0E~P&(4QDADwEE(1gO2HJHYi_ѯ0װwK1nj>c%qn:\&>`^iTn/
endstream
endobj
87 0 obj
<<
/XObject 249 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 250 0 R
>>
endobj
88 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 251 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
89 0 obj
<<
/Length 252 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im82 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F83 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
501.84 741.12 TD
(11) Tj
/F84 13.42 Tf
-416.40 -40.80 TD
(1 And the burden on us of this deviation from the rules) Tj
/F84 11.39 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 and the local order and your supplemental order is massive) Tj
/F84 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 because of the volume of documents that Apple has produced and) Tj
/F84 11.36 Tf
-.24 -25.20 TD
(4 the complete lack of structure to those documents.) Tj
/F83 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(5) Tj
/F84 11.47 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(Now, we have offered a variety of concessions. We) Tj
/F84 11.39 Tf
-85.92 -25.20 TD
(6 agreed not to seek the source information that's required by) Tj
/F84 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 the supplemental order, who the custodian was and how they) Tj
/F84 11.42 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(8 searched for the documents.) Tj
/F84 13.47 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(9 We requested in our briefing that they reproduce all) Tj
/F84 11.58 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 the documents sorted by document request. That would be very) Tj
/F84 11.56 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 burdensome. We would be willing to accept the folder structure) Tj
/F84 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 that shows us how these documents were kept in each individual) Tj
/F83 16.33 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(13 custodian i shands.) Tj
/F85 18.00 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 So we are doing our best to make this as minimally) Tj
/F84 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 burdensome for Apple as possible. But a giant array of) Tj
/F84 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 documents, one electronic file with a Bates label as its file) Tj
/F84 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 number per page is --) Tj
/F83 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F84 11.49 Tf
93.36 0.48 TD
(THE COURT: How hard would it be for you to give an) Tj
/F84 11.40 Tf
-93.36 -25.44 TD
(19 affidavit, Ms. Chung, that would say Bates numbers A through B) Tj
/F84 11.25 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 came from so and so's file i C through D came from somebody) Tj
/F84 11.62 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 else's file? How hard would it be for you to do that?) Tj
/F83 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F85 13.71 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Your Honor, we produced thousands of) Tj
/F84 11.60 Tf
-93.12 -25.44 TD
(23 pages and collected from many, many custodians. So at this) Tj
/F84 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 time, I cannot tell you how long that would take for us to) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 actually go back and correspon~ and correlate to this) Tj
/F85 9.69 Tf
159.84 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F84 8.10 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F84 7.77 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
90 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 253 0 R
>>
stream
x%̹0E~P&(4QDADynqQу6Jٓ"HYi_ѯ0װwK1nj>c%qn:\&>s^o91
endstream
endobj
91 0 obj
<<
/XObject 254 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 255 0 R
>>
endobj
92 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 256 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
93 0 obj
<<
/Length 257 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im89 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F90 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
502.08 740.64 TD
(12) Tj
/F91 11.15 Tf
-416.64 -41.04 TD
(1 information that you're seeking - - or Mr. Camara is seeking.) Tj
/F91 13.53 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(2 And I would like to correct one representation made) Tj
/F90 16.98 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 by Mr. Camara. He said he's not seeking a concession, the) Tj
/F92 16.71 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 source information. But that is not true.) Tj
/F91 13.74 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 He is absolutely seeking the source information) Tj
/F91 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(6 because he is seeking the file path and the folder structure) Tj
/F91 11.36 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(7 for every electronic document Apple has produced.) Tj
/F91 13.62 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 That is a tremendous amount of burden on Apple at) Tj
/F91 11.41 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 this time, when we are in the midst of expert discovery and) Tj
/F91 11.39 Tf
-6.72 -24.96 TD
(10 preparing for summary judgment stages, for us to do this at) Tj
/F91 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 this time.) Tj
/F90 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12) Tj
/F92 14.91 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, this is going to impose a) Tj
/F91 11.58 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(13 massive burden on one party or the other. There is no question) Tj
/F90 17.72 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(14 about that.) Tj
/F92 19.05 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 Either we do our best to reconstruct this and sort it) Tj
/F91 11.06 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(16 out by going through the documents manually, as we i ve done in) Tj
/F91 10.92 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 part and haven i t finished, or Apple does it.) Tj
/F92 19.15 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 The question, I would think, is it's much easier for) Tj
/F91 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 Apple to do this than it is for us to do that.) Tj
/F90 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F91 11.49 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: But, Your Honor, my point is that it was) Tj
/F91 11.05 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(21 Psystar' s burden, if they had any obj ections, to raise it) Tj
/F91 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 during fact discovery with prior counsel, or even when) Tj
/F91 11.38 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23 Mr. Camara joined as the representing counsel for Psystar.) Tj
/F92 18.35 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 And for them to ask now, even after fact discovery) Tj
/F90 17.43 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 deadline, is burdensome. And it i S actually besides -- it's) Tj
/F90 10.21 Tf
159.84 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F91 7.63 Tf
11.28 -10.80 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F91 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
94 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 258 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ
@F~/Xwfw+
&D ;A%C^qHiG. rHm~Ņi[9 vS-!p-։2TQ<J o3
endstream
endobj
95 0 obj
<<
/XObject 259 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 260 0 R
>>
endobj
96 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 261 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
97 0 obj
<<
/Length 262 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im96 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F97 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
502.56 741.12 TD
(13) Tj
/F98 11.34 Tf
-417.12 -41.04 TD
(1 beyond the time when they should have asked this information.) Tj
/F98 13.62 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(2 And he had the opportunity and the chance at every) Tj
/F98 11.40 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(3 deposition he took to ask questions about the documents, the) Tj
/F98 11.63 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 organization of the documents. And Mr. Camara and his) Tj
/F98 11.41 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 colleagues did not choose to do so.) Tj
/F98 13.51 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(6 So Apple should not be burdened, at this time, to do) Tj
/F98 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(7 the work for Psystar that they failed to do and they chose not) Tj
/F98 11.85 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 to do.) Tj
/F97 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9) Tj
/F98 11.77 Tf
85.92 0.48 TD
(MR. CAMRA: We raised this issue on the tenth day) Tj
/F98 11.43 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(10 after the fact discovery, which is the deadline in Your) Tj
/F98 5.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(11 Honor ) Tj
/F99 9.84 Tf
61.92 3.60 TD
(i s) Tj
/F99 18.79 Tf
-61.92 -28.32 TD
(12 THE COURT: I know, but that's literally the last day) Tj
/F98 11.65 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(13 it could be raised. I went back to check.) Tj
/F98 15.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 MR. CAMRA: I agree, Your Honor.) Tj
/F99 18.90 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(15 THE COURT: This is the kind of thing that) Tj
/F98 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(16 responsible counsel would have raised on the first time they) Tj
/F98 11.41 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 got documents that didn't comply, so that going forward it) Tj
/F99 15.83 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18 could be fixed.) Tj
/F99 18.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 And, instead, now you i re trying to go back to) Tj
/F98 11.43 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 re-litigate issues that were raised for the first time -- which) Tj
/F97 16.81 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(21 should have been raised a long time ago.) Tj
/F97 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F99 14.42 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, we certainly would have) Tj
/F97 17.77 Tf
-93.12 -25.44 TD
(23 preferred that these had been raised earlier.) Tj
/F98 13.47 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24 When we came in the case we made a strategic decision) Tj
/F97 16.55 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25 about what was most important. We decided preparing for those) Tj
/F97 9.57 Tf
159.84 -25.68 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF CJCFCCJCJ) Tj
/F98 7.66 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F98 7.86 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
98 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 263 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~R;3KI6іB0X
`k/- -.#K3ݚsS
;]6 SƱdžb}(S'F@% p35
endstream
endobj
99 0 obj
<<
/XObject 264 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 265 0 R
>>
endobj
100 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 266 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
101 0 obj
<<
/Length 267 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im103 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F104 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
501.36 742.08 TD
(14) Tj
/F105 11.22 Tf
-417.12 -41.52 TD
(1 depositions and taking those depositions - - which consumed many) Tj
/F105 11.39 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 of the business days in August, and for which a large part of) Tj
/F105 11.21 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 my team actually moved out to California - - was the priority at) Tj
/F105 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(4 that point. We don't think, though, that that strategic) Tj
/F105 11.36 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 decision excuses Apple's failure to comply with the rules.) Tj
/F105 13.50 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(6 We're not asking for a special concession because we) Tj
/F105 11.62 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(7 came into the case late. We're merely asking for the) Tj
/F105 11.22 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 information that the federal rules entitle us to. And we i re) Tj
/F105 11.51 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 not even asking for all --) Tj
/F104 11.28 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F105 11.50 Tf
93.36 0.48 TD
(THE COURT: They did entitle you to that way back) Tj
/F106 16.27 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(11 then. But I don i t think - - you just can It) Tj
/F105 13.36 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(12 Ms. Chung, are you prepared to swear under oath, now,) Tj
/F105 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 as to this prior agreement?) Tj
/F104 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(14) Tj
/F104 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
/F104 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F104 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F104 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F104 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20) Tj
/F104 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21) Tj
/F104 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F104 14.67 Tf
25.44 0.00 TD
(your) Tj
/F104 12.41 Tf
34.32 0.24 TD
(name?) Tj
/F104 11.52 Tf
-59.76 -25.44 TD
(23) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F106 13.44 Tf
92.16 274.56 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes, Your Honor.) Tj
/F105 11.45 Tf
0.48 -24.72 TD
(THE COURT: Please take the witness stand.) Tj
/F105 11.18 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(The clerk will swear in Ms. Chung.) Tj
/F105 11.46 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(THE CLERK: Please raise your right hand.) Tj
/F105 11.04 Tf
2.88 -25.92 TD
(\(The oath was administered to Ms. Chung.\)) Tj
/F104 13.54 Tf
-2.88 -23.76 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes.) Tj
/F106 13.90 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(THE CLERK: Please, be seated.) Tj
/F105 11.74 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(THE COURT: Ms. Chung, what's your name? What is) Tj
/F105 11.15 Tf
14.16 -24.96 TD
(Speak clearly into the microphone.) Tj
/F104 13.05 Tf
-14.16 -24.96 TD
(MS. CHUNG:' Megan Chung.) Tj
/F106 14.44 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(THE COURT: Is that mi crophone on? I don i t hear her.) Tj
/F105 11.56 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(THE CLERK: I thought it was.) Tj
/F106 9.49 Tf
66.48 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF CJCFC~) Tj
/F105 8.34 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - VS. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F105 7.83 Tf
45.84 -14.88 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
102 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 268 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;|RI%H|~$砤m%{$@!ӕ:bW_sna1~?c%f
ƅub}( >_jO~p7
endstream
endobj
103 0 obj
<<
/XObject 269 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 270 0 R
>>
endobj
104 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 271 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
105 0 obj
<<
/Length 272 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im110 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F111 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
502.08 741.12 TD
(15) Tj
/F111 9.60 Tf
-416.88 -40.08 TD
(1) Tj
/F112 11.10 Tf
86.16 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I t's not on.) Tj
/F111 10.08 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F113 11.77 Tf
89.76 -1.20 TD
(\(Pause. \)) Tj
/F111 9.12 Tf
-89.52 -23.76 TD
(3) Tj
/F111 13.37 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Megan Chung.) Tj
/F111 10.08 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F113 12.87 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Thank you.) Tj
/F111 9.60 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F112 11.21 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(What is your connection to this case?) Tj
/F111 9.60 Tf
-86.40 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F112 11.49 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I am counsel of record on behalf of) Tj
/F112 11.38 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(7 plaintiff and counter-defendant Apple Inc.) Tj
/F111 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F112 11.46 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Describe briefly what the issue is that) Tj
/F112 11.35 Tf
-86.40 -24.96 TD
(9 you were telling us about before you went under oath.) Tj
/F111 11.52 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F112 11.50 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Psystar filed a motion in which it had) Tj
/F112 11.40 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(11 stated that Apple -~ or it had requested that Apple provide) Tj
/F112 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12 folder structure information and source information for all) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 documents that Apple had produced.) Tj
/F113 17.90 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 But Apple had an agreement, it i S my belief, and I) Tj
/F111 17.69 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 participated on the call with Psystar' s lead trial counsel,) Tj
/F112 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 Mr. Robert Yorio and Colby Springer, about an agreement that) Tj
/F112 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 the parties do not provide source information, including) Tj
/F112 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 metadata, in September of 2008, with follow-up communications) Tj
/F112 11.46 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 in the fall of 2008.) Tj
/F111 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F112 11.86 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right. You're saying in) Tj
/F112 11.44 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(21 September 2008, you personally were in a conversation with) Tj
/F112 11.18 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 opposing counsel i is that correct?) Tj
/F111 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23) Tj
/F111 13.51 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes.) Tj
/F111 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F112 11.52 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: And was this in person or on the) Tj
/F112 11.82 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(25 telephone?) Tj
/F111 10.21 Tf
159.60 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F112 8.36 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - VS. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F112 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
106 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 273 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3,`3l-`D%<=h<;^2"$pXGrāfܒ|
;Ĝ+ ۱NƾVr9XwI+"Uq-9
endstream
endobj
107 0 obj
<<
/XObject 274 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 275 0 R
>>
endobj
108 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 276 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
109 0 obj
<<
/Length 277 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im117 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F118 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
501.60 741.60 TD
(16) Tj
/F118 9.60 Tf
-417.12 -41.04 TD
(1) Tj
/F119 11.49 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We talked on the telephone to start our) Tj
/F119 11.52 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(2 26\(f\) conference.) Tj
/F118 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F119 11.52 Tf
86.88 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: And who else was present?) Tj
/F118 9.60 Tf
-86.88 -25.20 TD
(4) Tj
/F119 11.51 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Mr. Gilliland, James Gilliland, and) Tj
/F119 11.34 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(5 Mehrnaz Boroumand Smith, of Townsend, Townsend and Crew,) Tj
/F119 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(6 representing Apple Inc., participated on the conference call) Tj
/F119 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 with Mr. Robert Yorio and Mr. Colby Springer representing) Tj
/F119 11.47 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(8 Psystar Corporation.) Tj
/F118 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9) Tj
/F119 11.73 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right. Specifically, what was said) Tj
/F119 11.41 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(10 by each side? Don i t use conclusory language. What was said by) Tj
/F119 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 each side on this subject?) Tj
/F118 11.04 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12) Tj
/F119 11.51 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: At the time of the 26\(f\) conference in) Tj
/F119 11.42 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(13 September, we discussed specifically our document production) Tj
/F120 14.33 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 and Your Honor i s supplemental standing order.) Tj
/F119 13.90 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(15 Ms. Boroumand Smith raised the issue of the) Tj
/F119 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(16 requirements in Judge Alsup's supplemental standing order with) Tj
/F119 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 respect to the privilege log and document production, and that) Tj
/F119 11.42 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(18 it would be burdensome for the parties to have to provide such) Tj
/F118 17.37 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 information at the time of the production and of the service of) Tj
/F119 11.94 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 the privilege log. Mr.) Tj
/F119 11.20 Tf
209.76 0.48 TD
(I can't recall specifically if it) Tj
/F119 11.41 Tf
-209.52 -25.44 TD
(21 was Mr. Yorio or Mr. Springer who agreed.) Tj
/F120 19.23 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 And then it was followed up with specifically) Tj
/F118 17.26 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(23 conversation about metadata that - - and I believe that issue) Tj
/F119 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 was raised by, again, Ms. Boroumand Smith, and that we would be) Tj
/F119 11.37 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25 also excluding the source information in the form of metadata,) Tj
/F118 10.29 Tf
159.60 -25.68 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF CJCF C~) Tj
/F119 8.12 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F119 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
110 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 278 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
112 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 281 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
113 0 obj
<<
/Length 282 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im124 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F125 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
502.08 740.16 TD
(17) Tj
/F126 11.58 Tf
-417.36 -40.08 TD
(1 with the possible -- no. So that we would be excluding the) Tj
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 source information of the metadata. And Mr. Springer agreed to) Tj
/F125 19.97 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 that.) Tj
/F126 13.65 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 And then Mr. Gilliland said with the exception of) Tj
/F126 11.41 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 possibility the Web site content, because Psystar may be) Tj
/F126 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 changing their Web site content and we may need to be able to) Tj
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7 see the information with respect to the metadata on that) Tj
/F126 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 Web site content. To which Mr. Springer responded that they) Tj
/F126 11.36 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9 would need to talk to Psystar about Web site information.) Tj
/F127 18.43 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 Following that conversation, I had a conversation) Tj
/F126 11.59 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 with Mr. Springer about Web site information. And then another) Tj
/F126 11.44 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12 conversation, I believe, Ms. Boroumand Smith had with) Tj
/F126 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 Mr. Springer, where the issue of version control came up for) Tj
/F126 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 the source code, Psystar source code and the Web site) Tj
/F126 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 information. And we discovered that Psystar did not maintain) Tj
/F126 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 version control for the source code or for the Web site, so the) Tj
/F126 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 metadata issue with respect to the Web site became moot.) Tj
/F125 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18) Tj
/F126 11.73 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: All right. Any questions, Mr. Camara?) Tj
/F125 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F127 14.10 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: You mentioned that you reached an) Tj
/F127 15.04 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(20 agreement with Mr. Yorio and Mr. Springer about what is) Tj
/F126 11.06 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 required to be produced under Judge Alsup i s standing) Tj
/F126 11.44 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(22 supplemental order in civil caseSi is that right?) Tj
/F125 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23) Tj
/F125 13.54 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes.) Tj
/F125 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F127 14.96 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Did you further discuss the scope of) Tj
/F126 11.09 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(25 Apple i s obligations under the federal rules, setting aside the) Tj
/F125 10.37 Tf
160.08 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F126 8.12 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F126 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
114 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 283 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
116 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 286 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
117 0 obj
<<
/Length 287 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im131 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F132 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
502.56 740.64 TD
(18) Tj
/F133 11.50 Tf
-416.88 -40.80 TD
(1 special supplemental order?) Tj
/F132 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F133 11.46 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We discussed further that we would not be) Tj
/F133 11.34 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(3 providing/producing electronic documents in its native format.) Tj
/F134 15.49 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 That, instead, we would be - - the parties - - now, I don i t) Tj
/F133 11.38 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 remember if we raised it or if Mr. Yorio raised the issue, but) Tj
/F133 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 that the counsel on the conference call in September agreed) Tj
/F133 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7 that we would be producing the documents not in its native) Tj
/F133 11.21 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 format but, rather, in PDF and TIF electronic - - searchable) Tj
/F133 11.48 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 electronic format.) Tj
/F134 18.59 Tf
-6.72 -24.96 TD
(10 After that conversation, Psystar counsel - - I can It) Tj
/F133 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 remember if it was Mr. Springer or now Mr. Grewe who raised the) Tj
/F133 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 issue of producing a hard copy.) Tj
/F132 10.80 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F133 11.73 Tf
92.88 0.48 TD
(MR. CAMRA: And, in fact, that agreement was reduced) Tj
/F133 11.39 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(14 to writing about not producing in native format, right?) Tj
/F132 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
/F133 11.76 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Actually, I cannot recall that. I) Tj
/F132 16.24 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(16 don It - - I don i t remember seeing that.) Tj
/F132 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F134 14.69 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Okay. So you mentioned one part of the) Tj
/F133 11.40 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(18 federal rules you discussed, which is whether you would produce) Tj
/F133 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 in native format.) Tj
/F134 17.71 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 Did you discuss in any other way Apple i s obligations) Tj
/F133 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21 under the federal rules, setting aside, again, the supplemental) Tj
/F133 12.09 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 order?) Tj
/F132 11.28 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F134 13.43 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: We never discussed about Apple i s) Tj
/F134 16.23 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(24 obligations.) Tj
/F132 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F133 11.49 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, that i s our point. Our point) Tj
/F132 10.20 Tf
66.72 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fivanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F133 8.10 Tf
11.28 -10.80 TD
(Offa\( CRorter - VS. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F133 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
118 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 288 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
120 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 291 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
121 0 obj
<<
/Length 292 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im138 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F139 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
501.84 740.40 TD
(19) Tj
/F140 11.53 Tf
-416.64 -39.84 TD
(1 is that even setting aside) Tj
/F139 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F140 11.44 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Have you finished your examination?) Tj
/F139 9.12 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(3) Tj
/F141 14.08 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Why did you not reduce the agreement you) Tj
/F140 11.39 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(4 entered into about the supplemental order to writing?) Tj
/F139 9.60 Tf
0.48 -25.20 TD
(5) Tj
/F141 13.13 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I i m sorry?) Tj
/F139 9.60 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F141 14.99 Tf
86.16 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: You testified that you didn i t reduce the) Tj
/F140 11.41 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(7 agreement you reached with Mr. Springer and Mr. Yorio in) Tj
/F140 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(8 September of 2008, to writing.) Tj
/F141 20.53 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(9 You didnlt reduce it to writingi is that right?) Tj
/F139 11.52 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F139 5.00 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MS. ) Tj
/F140 11.50 Tf
27.36 -.24 TD
(CHUNG: I thought either myself or Ms. Boroumand) Tj
/F140 11.57 Tf
-120.00 -24.72 TD
(11 Smith had reduced it to writing to opposing counsel. But when) Tj
/F140 11.33 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(12 we searched, since you filed your motion, we could not find it.) Tj
/F139 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13) Tj
/F141 14.55 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: And is it customary at Townsend to) Tj
/F141 14.78 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(14 reduce agreements with opposing counsel to writing?) Tj
/F139 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
/F140 11.49 Tf
92.64 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Normally, when we have good relationship) Tj
/F140 11.40 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(16 with opposing counsel, it is not my practice to reduce it in) Tj
/F141 16.85 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 writing.) Tj
/F139 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F140 11.74 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: So an agreement like this, about the) Tj
/F140 11.04 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(19 form of all of Apple i s discovery, you would not have sent a) Tj
/F140 11.39 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 confirming e-mail to opposing counsel? That is not Townsend iS) Tj
/F139 17.49 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 practice?) Tj
/F139 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F140 11.52 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I can't speak for Townsend practice) Tj
/F140 10.96 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(23 because we don i t necessarily have a policy on that.) Tj
/F139 11.52 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(24) Tj
/F141 15.43 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. CARA: And it i S not your practice to send a) Tj
/F141 16.10 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(25 confirming --) Tj
/F141 10.95 Tf
159.60 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSu\(fvanJ CSCF ~C~) Tj
/F140 8.36 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'US. CDtrit Court) Tj
/F140 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
122 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 293 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3k3l-`D%<%=h<;^D[[8[GͶ+vs>3[7:Vr|+JH% r8
endstream
endobj
123 0 obj
<<
/XObject 294 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 295 0 R
>>
endobj
124 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 296 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
125 0 obj
<<
/Length 297 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im145 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F146 11.76 Tf
100 Tz
501.36 740.64 TD
(20) Tj
/F146 9.60 Tf
-416.16 -40.80 TD
(1) Tj
/F147 11.60 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: My practice is not) Tj
/F146 16.47 Tf
231.12 0.48 TD
(I - - my practice) Tj
/F147 11.38 Tf
-317.28 -25.68 TD
(2 is, generally, to reduce in writing only if I feel it will) Tj
/F147 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 become an issue and when all the issues have been met and) Tj
/F147 11.38 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 conferred with opposing counsel and decided.) Tj
/F146 9.60 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F148 14.88 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: If you had reduced other issues to) Tj
/F147 11.20 Tf
-85.92 -24.96 TD
(6 writing in this case - - for example, if i told you there were) Tj
/F147 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 writings that evidence your agreement about not providing) Tj
/F147 11.41 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(8 native format files, would you then be surprised that you) Tj
/F147 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 didnlt reduce this other agreement to writing?) Tj
/F146 11.28 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F146 13.28 Tf
92.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: No.) Tj
/F146 11.52 Tf
-92.40 -25.20 TD
(11) Tj
/F148 14.75 Tf
92.40 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: You said you only reduce things to) Tj
/F147 11.39 Tf
-92.40 -24.96 TD
(12 writing when you have an adversarial relationship with opposing) Tj
/F147 11.08 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(13 counsel i is that right?) Tj
/F146 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14) Tj
/F147 11.51 Tf
92.40 0.00 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I do not reduce to writing if I have a) Tj
/F147 11.38 Tf
-92.40 -24.96 TD
(15 good relationship with opposing counsel.) Tj
/F146 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(16) Tj
/F148 14.64 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Do you have a good relationship with) Tj
/F148 15.77 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(17 Carr & Ferrell?) Tj
/F146 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F147 11.52 Tf
92.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: At the time of the 26 conference and in) Tj
/F147 11.36 Tf
-92.40 -25.20 TD
(19 2008, yes, we were able to reach many agreements.) Tj
/F146 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20) Tj
/F147 11.78 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Would it surprise you, then, that you) Tj
/F147 11.35 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(21 reduced to writing all kinds of agreements with Carr & Ferrell,) Tj
/F146 16.77 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 including agreements about e-mail service, about the production) Tj
/F147 11.44 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(23 of documents in native format, and about a host of other) Tj
/F146 17.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 topics?) Tj
/F146 11.76 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(25) Tj
/F147 11.07 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I don i t believe I reduced to writing) Tj
/F148 9.90 Tf
66.72 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSuffivan, CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F147 8.10 Tf
11.28 -10.80 TD
(offf CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F147 7.80 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
126 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 298 0 R
>>
stream
x%ȹ0E~PόM:VQQDADwEEb0ϞeДБ࿅zY0l[[qaaK1nj>c{8riU,ɧ*:bTo;1
endstream
endobj
127 0 obj
<<
/XObject 299 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 300 0 R
>>
endobj
128 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 301 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
129 0 obj
<<
/Length 302 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im152 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F153 12.00 Tf
100 Tz
501.84 741.12 TD
(21) Tj
/F154 11.55 Tf
-416.64 -40.80 TD
(1 those topics.) Tj
/F153 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F155 14.65 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Are you aware of whether or not other) Tj
/F154 11.39 Tf
-86.16 -25.20 TD
(3 members of the Townsend, Townsend and Crew team present here) Tj
/F154 11.44 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 habitually reduced agreements to writing?) Tj
/F153 9.60 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F154 11.45 Tf
86.16 0.48 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Well, I don't know about "habitually,") Tj
/F154 11.38 Tf
-86.16 -25.44 TD
(6 but I do know that they have reduced to writing some agreements) Tj
/F154 11.45 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7 with Carr & Ferrell.) Tj
/F153 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F155 13.98 Tf
86.16 0.48 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Have you seen Ms. Smith reducing) Tj
/F154 11.53 Tf
-85.92 -25.44 TD
(9 agreements to writing?) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F154 11.49 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(MS. CHUNG: I have seen her reduce -- put in writing) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(11) Tj
/F153 15.91 Tf
25.68 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F153 14.49 Tf
27.36 0.24 TD
(agreements) Tj
/F154 11.24 Tf
73.68 0.00 TD
(with Carr) Tj
/F154 10.68 Tf
68.88 0.24 TD
(& Ferrell,) Tj
/F155 16.08 Tf
74.16 0.00 TD
(especially this) Tj
/F153 15.71 Tf
107.76 0.48 TD
(year,) Tj
/F153 16.05 Tf
41.52 0.00 TD
(in) Tj
/F153 11.28 Tf
-419.04 -25.68 TD
(12) Tj
/F153 13.66 Tf
25.92 0.00 TD
(2009.) Tj
/F153 11.28 Tf
-25.92 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F153 10.00 Tf
93.36 0.48 TD
(THE) Tj
/F153 10.41 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F154 11.20 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(How much more) Tj
/F153 12.48 Tf
95.28 0.24 TD
(do) Tj
/F154 11.07 Tf
19.92 0.00 TD
(you have?) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-289.92 -25.44 TD
(14) Tj
/F153 9.96 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F153 11.38 Tf
27.36 -.24 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F153 15.41 Tf
61.20 0.24 TD
(That's) Tj
/F153 20.25 Tf
48.24 0.24 TD
(it,) Tj
/F153 12.97 Tf
26.16 0.00 TD
(Your) Tj
/F153 13.61 Tf
33.84 0.00 TD
(Honor.) Tj
/F153 11.28 Tf
-289.68 -25.44 TD
(15) Tj
/F153 10.00 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F153 10.34 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F153 15.41 Tf
53.76 0.24 TD
(All) Tj
/F153 17.40 Tf
28.32 0.00 TD
(right.) Tj
/F153 12.87 Tf
54.00 0.24 TD
(Thank) Tj
/F153 14.13 Tf
40.08 0.00 TD
(you.) Tj
/F153 11.28 Tf
-296.40 -25.68 TD
(16) Tj
/F153 11.46 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(Ms.) Tj
/F153 12.75 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(Chung,) Tj
/F154 11.26 Tf
47.04 0.24 TD
(you can) Tj
/F153 15.95 Tf
55.44 0.00 TD
(step) Tj
/F153 12.53 Tf
33.36 0.00 TD
(down.) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-256.32 -25.44 TD
(17) Tj
/F155 11.68 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(Here IS) Tj
/F153 15.52 Tf
48.00 -.24 TD
(the) Tj
/F153 14.41 Tf
27.12 0.24 TD
(answer.) Tj
/F153 13.69 Tf
61.68 0.24 TD
(I) Tj
/F153 15.77 Tf
12.96 -.24 TD
(donlt) Tj
/F153 12.21 Tf
40.32 0.24 TD
(know) Tj
/F153 14.61 Tf
33.84 0.24 TD
(whether) Tj
/F154 10.98 Tf
54.72 0.00 TD
(there was) Tj
/F153 13.48 Tf
67.44 0.00 TD
(an) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-439.20 -25.68 TD
(18) Tj
/F153 14.29 Tf
25.92 0.00 TD
(agreement) Tj
/F154 10.57 Tf
67.68 0.24 TD
(or not.) Tj
/F153 18.91 Tf
61.44 0.00 TD
(It's) Tj
/F154 11.20 Tf
33.60 0.00 TD
(too hard) Tj
/F153 15.74 Tf
61.44 0.24 TD
(to) Tj
/F153 20.11 Tf
20.16 0.00 TD
(tell.) Tj
/F153 13.69 Tf
48.00 0.24 TD
(I) Tj
/F153 15.88 Tf
13.20 0.00 TD
(think) Tj
/F153 11.62 Tf
39.84 0.24 TD
(Ms.) Tj
/F153 12.33 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(Chung) Tj
/F153 16.92 Tf
41.04 0.00 TD
(is) Tj
/F153 11.52 Tf
-439.68 -25.92 TD
(19) Tj
/F153 16.31 Tf
25.68 0.00 TD
(acting) Tj
/F153 15.74 Tf
48.00 0.24 TD
(in) Tj
/F153 13.33 Tf
19.44 0.00 TD
(good) Tj
/F153 17.81 Tf
34.56 0.00 TD
(faith) Tj
/F153 15.74 Tf
40.80 0.00 TD
(in) Tj
/F153 15.99 Tf
20.16 0.00 TD
(thinking) Tj
/F153 16.21 Tf
61.20 0.24 TD
(there) Tj
/F153 12.50 Tf
40.08 0.24 TD
(was) Tj
/F154 10.83 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(an agreement,) Tj
/F153 15.03 Tf
94.32 0.24 TD
(but) Tj
/F153 11.76 Tf
-412.08 -25.92 TD
(20) Tj
/F153 12.51 Tf
25.44 0.24 TD
(maybe) Tj
/F153 15.32 Tf
41.52 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F153 16.12 Tf
26.64 0.00 TD
(other) Tj
/F153 15.95 Tf
41.04 0.00 TD
(side) Tj
/F154 9.43 Tf
33.60 0.00 TD
(didnl t) Tj
/F153 12.62 Tf
47.52 0.24 TD
(know.) Tj
/F153 12.00 Tf
-215.76 -25.20 TD
(21) Tj
/F153 16.09 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(Here i s the main point. This whole - - I i m not going) Tj
/F154 11.53 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(22 to rule on that. This should have been raised a long time ago,) Tj
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23 if it was a problem. Now you're raising it way after the fact,) Tj
/F153 17.62 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24 and it i s too late to reorganize things.) Tj
/F153 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F154 11.25 Tf
94.32 0.24 TD
(I'm sympathetic to your issue, so herels what welre) Tj
/F153 9.52 Tf
65.52 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF CJCFCCJCJ) Tj
/F154 8.11 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F154 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
130 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 303 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~R;3KI6іB0X
`kQNꑥ@]n\N q|FgcÅU\>W]TI!PI?o3
endstream
endobj
131 0 obj
<<
/XObject 304 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 305 0 R
>>
endobj
132 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 306 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
133 0 obj
<<
/Length 307 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im159 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F160 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
502.80 740.16 TD
(22) Tj
/F161 11.69 Tf
-416.64 -40.80 TD
(1 going to do. Write this down. Each side, by Tuesday at noon,) Tj
/F161 11.39 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 can send a letter to the other side and identify up to 50) Tj
/F161 11.58 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 pages, and say, "Tell me where these 50 pages came from." And) Tj
/F161 11.34 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 then the other side has got to respond by Friday of next week,) Tj
/F161 11.41 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 say, "Here's the file that it came from.") Tj
/F160 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F161 11.24 Tf
87.12 0.48 TD
(For example, you would want to say Mr. Vidrine's desk) Tj
/F161 11.40 Tf
-87.12 -25.20 TD
(7 file hard copy. That would be adequate. Or Vidrine i s computer) Tj
/F161 11.72 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(8 e-mails.) Tj
/F161 13.22 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 So each of you can pick out the 50 you i re most) Tj
/F161 11.35 Tf
-6.96 -24.96 TD
(10 interested in knowing about, and serve it on the other side.) Tj
/F162 14.58 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 And you i 11 learn where the sources were for those 50.) Tj
/F162 17.73 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12 But beyond that, we are not going to go back and redo) Tj
/F161 11.22 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 it for all the other documents in the case, most of which don It) Tj
/F160 16.88 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 matter anyway. And so you pick out the 50 that you care about.) Tj
/F160 16.53 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 5 0 individual pages.) Tj
/F160 19.48 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(16 Now, if it happens to be a 30-page document, you can) Tj
/F161 11.54 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 pick out the first page. And then the other 30, presumably,) Tj
/F162 14.89 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 came from the same source. So you can do that.) Tj
/F160 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F161 11.26 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(But you canlt then object on the ground, oh, theylve) Tj
/F161 11.38 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(20 used up 30 pages because it was a 30 -page document. No.) Tj
/F161 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 That i s one page. In away, this is like 50 different documents) Tj
/F161 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(22 or 50 different pages.) Tj
/F160 11.52 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F162 14.22 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(You need Bates number. Each of you used unique Bates) Tj
/F162 15.11 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(24 numbers, right?) Tj
/F160 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F160 14.49 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Yes, Your Honor.) Tj
/F162 9.60 Tf
66.72 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFowe\(\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF CJCFC~) Tj
/F161 8.08 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F161 7.83 Tf
45.84 -14.88 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
134 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 308 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~R;3KI6іB0X
`k
QNꑥ@]n\N q|FgcÅU\>W]T˓pC~p55
endstream
endobj
135 0 obj
<<
/XObject 309 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 310 0 R
>>
endobj
136 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 311 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
137 0 obj
<<
/Length 312 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im166 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F167 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
502.56 740.16 TD
(23) Tj
/F167 9.60 Tf
-416.64 -40.56 TD
(1) Tj
/F167 10.62 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MS.) Tj
/F167 9.90 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(CHUNG:) Tj
/F167 13.43 Tf
54.00 0.00 TD
(Yes.) Tj
/F167 10.08 Tf
-168.00 -25.20 TD
(2) Tj
/F167 10.00 Tf
87.12 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F167 10.34 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F167 13.46 Tf
53.76 0.00 TD
(Give) Tj
/F167 13.32 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(them) Tj
/F167 12.97 Tf
33.84 0.00 TD
(a) Tj
/F167 20.81 Tf
13.92 0.24 TD
(list) Tj
/F167 14.41 Tf
33.60 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F167 15.32 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 11.52 Tf
27.12 0.24 TD
(50) Tj
/F168 11.08 Tf
19.44 0.00 TD
(Bates numbers) Tj
/F167 9.12 Tf
-350.40 -25.68 TD
(3) Tj
/F167 13.45 Tf
18.72 0.00 TD
(you) Tj
/F167 15.72 Tf
27.60 0.24 TD
(are) Tj
/F169 15.89 Tf
27.84 0.00 TD
(interested in.) Tj
/F167 11.85 Tf
106.80 0.00 TD
(And) Tj
/F167 15.52 Tf
28.08 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 16.00 Tf
26.88 0.24 TD
(other) Tj
/F167 15.95 Tf
41.04 0.00 TD
(side) Tj
/F167 14.23 Tf
33.36 0.24 TD
(has) Tj
/F167 14.65 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(got) Tj
/F167 15.74 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(to) Tj
/F167 14.97 Tf
20.16 0.00 TD
(respond.) Tj
/F167 10.08 Tf
-384.72 -25.68 TD
(4) Tj
/F167 13.12 Tf
19.68 0.00 TD
(Say) Tj
/F167 15.72 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 12.08 Tf
26.88 0.24 TD
(name) Tj
/F167 14.41 Tf
34.08 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F167 15.52 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 15.31 Tf
26.40 0.00 TD
(person.) Tj
/F167 10.81 Tf
60.96 0.24 TD
(Was) Tj
/F167 20.73 Tf
28.08 0.00 TD
(it) Tj
/F167 12.97 Tf
19.68 0.00 TD
(a) Tj
/F167 15.13 Tf
13.44 0.00 TD
(hard) Tj
/F167 13.17 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(copy?) Tj
/F167 10.81 Tf
46.32 0.24 TD
(Was) Tj
/F167 20.73 Tf
27.84 0.00 TD
(it) Tj
/F167 12.43 Tf
19.92 0.00 TD
(a) Tj
/F167 14.28 Tf
13.44 0.00 TD
(desk) Tj
/F167 9.60 Tf
-418.08 -25.68 TD
(5) Tj
/F167 17.83 Tf
19.44 0.24 TD
(file?) Tj
/F168 11.05 Tf
46.80 0.00 TD
(What was) Tj
/F167 15.52 Tf
61.44 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 11.97 Tf
26.64 0.00 TD
(name) Tj
/F167 14.70 Tf
33.84 0.00 TD
(of) Tj
/F167 15.52 Tf
20.64 0.00 TD
(the) Tj
/F167 19.11 Tf
27.36 0.24 TD
(file,) Tj
/F167 19.25 Tf
40.80 0.24 TD
(if) Tj
/F168 10.67 Tf
20.64 0.00 TD
(it was) Tj
/F167 12.97 Tf
46.32 0.00 TD
(a) Tj
/F167 14.41 Tf
13.20 0.00 TD
(desk) Tj
/F167 17.83 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(file?) Tj
/F168 13.21 Tf
-391.44 -25.44 TD
(6 For example, if. the name of the desk file said, "Ways) Tj
/F169 15.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(7 to suppress competition," then you would say, "Vidrine i s file) Tj
/F168 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 on ways to suppress competition.") Tj
/F167 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9) Tj
/F169 13.42 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes, Your Honor.) Tj
/F167 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(10) Tj
/F169 14.64 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, might we also ask for a) Tj
/F168 11.39 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(11 small award of fees for the bringing of this motion?) Tj
/F167 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12) Tj
/F167 10.13 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(THE) Tj
/F167 10.34 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F167 12.07 Tf
53.76 0.00 TD
(No.) Tj
/F167 11.04 Tf
-174.24 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F167 10.10 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F167 11.32 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F167 12.97 Tf
60.72 0.00 TD
(Thank) Tj
/F167 13.85 Tf
40.32 0.00 TD
(you,) Tj
/F168 10.87 Tf
34.32 0.00 TD
(Your Honor.) Tj
/F167 11.28 Tf
-256.08 -24.96 TD
(14) Tj
/F167 10.00 Tf
93.60 0.00 TD
(THE) Tj
/F167 10.28 Tf
27.12 0.00 TD
(COURT:) Tj
/F168 11.24 Tf
53.76 0.24 TD
(Because you) Tj
/F167 15.72 Tf
81.84 0.00 TD
(are) Tj
/F167 16.18 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(lucky to) Tj
/F167 15.32 Tf
60.24 0.24 TD
(get) Tj
/F167 17.99 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(this.) Tj
/F167 11.85 Tf
46.32 0.24 TD
(And) Tj
/F167 11.28 Tf
-417.60 -25.68 TD
(15) Tj
/F167 15.26 Tf
25.20 0.00 TD
(both) Tj
/F167 16.09 Tf
34.80 0.24 TD
(sides) Tj
/F167 15.72 Tf
40.32 0.00 TD
(are) Tj
/F167 14.44 Tf
26.88 0.00 TD
(going) Tj
/F168 10.87 Tf
40.80 0.00 TD
(to get) Tj
/F167 20.85 Tf
48.00 0.24 TD
(it.) Tj
/F169 13.29 Tf
33.12 0.00 TD
(You are) Tj
/F167 14.55 Tf
54.48 0.00 TD
(going) Tj
/F168 10.91 Tf
40.80 0.24 TD
(to have) Tj
/F167 16.05 Tf
54.00 0.00 TD
(to) Tj
/F167 11.28 Tf
-398.40 -25.44 TD
(16) Tj
/F167 14.97 Tf
25.68 0.00 TD
(respond,) Tj
/F167 15.55 Tf
61.44 0.00 TD
(too.) Tj
/F169 17.42 Tf
-87.12 -24.96 TD
(17 This motion should have been brought a long time ago.) Tj
/F168 11.07 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18 The fact that it wasn i t does tend to indicate there was an) Tj
/F169 14.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 agreement. Then new counsel came in and decided to go a) Tj
/F168 11.60 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 different way.) Tj
/F169 18.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 So I i m not ruling that there was or was not an) Tj
/F169 15.50 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 agreement. 11m just saying for the sake of making this an) Tj
/F168 11.43 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(23 easier case for both of you to try and get organized, it would) Tj
/F168 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 be useful for you to have that information.) Tj
/F167 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F168 11.49 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(Okay. So what else do I need to decide today?) Tj
/F169 9.83 Tf
66.24 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSuffivan, CSCF CJCFC~) Tj
/F167 10.81 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Offciaf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F167 10.56 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
138 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 313 0 R
>>
stream
x%̹0E~PόM:VQQDADynqQу6'{A#?gȳaٶ~E4_Nb5|xFqnҪX.Ougy>PE?p7
endstream
endobj
139 0 obj
<<
/XObject 314 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 315 0 R
>>
endobj
140 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 316 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
141 0 obj
<<
/Length 317 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im173 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F174 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
501.36 740.88 TD
(24) Tj
/F174 10.08 Tf
-416.88 -40.56 TD
(1) Tj
/F175 11.72 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: I believe the plaintiffs have requested) Tj
/F175 11.58 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(2 a status conference about the Florida matter. We have no other) Tj
/F175 11.50 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 discovery disputes.) Tj
/F174 10.08 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F175 11.69 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: All right. Whatls the deal on -- what do) Tj
/F175 11.44 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(5 you want, Ms. Chung, on the Florida matter?) Tj
/F174 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F175 11.49 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Actually, Mr. Gilliland will be speaking) Tj
/F175 11.53 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(7 on that matter.) Tj
/F174 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F175 11.60 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right.) Tj
/F174 9.60 Tf
-86.64 -25.20 TD
(9) Tj
/F176 13.51 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Thank you, Your Honor.) Tj
/F174 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(10) Tj
/F174 14.69 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Good morning, Your Honor.) Tj
/F174 11.76 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(11) Tj
/F176 12.81 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Good morning.) Tj
/F174 11.28 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(12) Tj
/F176 16.05 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: First, I want to thank you for) Tj
/F175 11.36 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(13 carving the time out of your schedule to meet with us today.) Tj
/F174 20.99 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 The reason that Apple asked for this status) Tj
/F175 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 conference is because of the filing last week of a complaint in) Tj
/F175 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 the Southern District of Florida, in which Psystar basically) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 mimics the allegations and claims that are pending here and) Tj
/F175 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 which will be resolved, we believe, at trial in January. So in) Tj
/F175 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 the interest of efficiency and not asking the courts to do) Tj
/F175 11.44 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 duplicative labor, we wanted to talk with Your Honor about how) Tj
/F175 11.58 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 to now proceed.) Tj
/F176 18.84 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 Basically, the case filed in Florida, which we have) Tj
/F174 17.68 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(23 submitted to the Court, asked for declaratory relief that) Tj
/F176 15.80 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 Psystar does not infringe Apple's copyrights by loading its) Tj
/F175 11.46 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(25 Apple software onto Psystar computers that Psystar does not) Tj
/F176 9.98 Tf
160.32 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSu\(fvan, CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F175 7.87 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(offf CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict. Court) Tj
/F174 10.56 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
142 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 318 0 R
>>
stream
x%90~NK(gF*J"Y6
NDXϏ%PӃց'{C#E"/FmWtK.M54s: l3[7p*Q3L\9Wq/9
endstream
endobj
143 0 obj
<<
/XObject 319 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 320 0 R
>>
endobj
144 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 321 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
145 0 obj
<<
/Length 322 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im180 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F181 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
503.04 740.16 TD
(25) Tj
/F182 11.38 Tf
-416.64 -39.36 TD
(1 violate the Digital Millennium Copyright Act by circumventing a) Tj
/F182 11.59 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(2 technological protection measure. And those issues, as the) Tj
/F182 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 Court well knows, are precisely the ones set forth in this) Tj
/F183 16.87 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(4 lawsuit.) Tj
/F181 22.11 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 Psystar, also in Florida, reasserts the antitrust) Tj
/F182 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(6 causes of action that this Court already considered and) Tj
/F182 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 dismissed in November of 2008.) Tj
/F181 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F182 11.49 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(So the question presented, of course, is: Why did) Tj
/F183 15.63 Tf
-86.40 -24.72 TD
(9 they do that? What i s the basis for arguing that there should) Tj
/F183 15.67 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 be a separate lawsuit in Florida?) Tj
/F183 18.92 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(11 And Psystar i s justification, which we think is) Tj
/F182 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 groundless, is that the Florida action involves Version 10.6 of) Tj
/F183 14.67 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 Apple i s operating system, called a Snow Leopard. And as) Tj
/F182 11.41 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(14 represented to the Court in Florida, this lawsuit in California) Tj
/F182 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(15 only involves Version 10.5, which is called "Leopard.") Tj
/F181 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F182 11.68 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Is called what?) Tj
/F181 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F181 14.83 Tf
92.64 0.00 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Leopard.) Tj
/F181 11.28 Tf
-92.64 -24.72 TD
(18) Tj
/F182 11.77 Tf
92.88 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Leper --) Tj
/F181 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F181 15.70 Tf
92.64 0.00 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: L-e-o-p-a-r-d.) Tj
/F181 12.00 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F183 12.89 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Leopard.) Tj
/F181 12.00 Tf
-93.36 -24.72 TD
(21) Tj
/F181 14.85 Tf
92.88 -.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Leopard.) Tj
/F181 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -24.72 TD
(22) Tj
/F182 11.49 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: The other one was Snow Leopard, but this) Tj
/F182 11.71 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(23 is Leopard?) Tj
/F181 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F183 15.00 Tf
92.88 -.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: That i s correct. One has spots and) Tj
/F182 11.43 Tf
-92.88 -24.72 TD
(25 the other is white or something.) Tj
/F183 9.83 Tf
159.84 -26.40 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~ CCCJ) Tj
/F182 8.12 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F181 10.56 Tf
45.84 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
146 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 323 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3,`3l-`D%<=h<;^3"$pXGrāfܒ|
;Ĝ+ ۱NƾVr9XwI+"Uq;
endstream
endobj
147 0 obj
<<
/XObject 324 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 325 0 R
>>
endobj
148 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 326 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
149 0 obj
<<
/Length 327 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im187 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F188 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
501.84 740.16 TD
(26) Tj
/F188 9.60 Tf
-416.64 -40.32 TD
(1) Tj
/F188 16.13 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MR. CARA: They both have spots.) Tj
/F188 9.60 Tf
-86.16 -25.20 TD
(2) Tj
/F188 15.78 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: But the representation, Your Honor,) Tj
/F189 11.39 Tf
-85.92 -25.20 TD
(3 that this lawsuit only involves Leopard, or Version 10.5, is) Tj
/F188 17.47 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 wrong. That's not what our allegations say. And those are not) Tj
/F189 11.36 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 the only issues that will be resolved by this Court.) Tj
/F189 13.51 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(6 If you will indulge me for a moment, i will show you) Tj
/F189 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 references to our complaint.) Tj
/F188 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F189 11.64 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right.) Tj
/F188 9.12 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(9) Tj
/F188 15.44 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: These are quotes from the amended) Tj
/F190 15.17 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(10 complaint.) Tj
/F188 20.21 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(11 Paragraph 15 says that in October, 2008, Psystar) Tj
/F189 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 announced it was going to sell new products with a new) Tj
/F188 16.24 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 unauthorized version of Mac OS X operating system. That i s not) Tj
/F189 11.57 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 limited to Version 10.5 or Version 10.6. It's Mac OS X.) Tj
/F188 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(15) Tj
/F189 11.26 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(In Paragraph 24 we allege that Apple never authorized) Tj
/F189 11.51 Tf
-93.84 -25.20 TD
(16 Psystar to install any of Mac OS, Mac operating system. Again,) Tj
/F189 11.46 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(17 not limited to Version 10.) Tj
/F190 18.49 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18 With respect to the copyright infringement actions,) Tj
/F189 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 we do specifically reference this is Leopard, but we also) Tj
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 allege that they have infringed our copyright in Mac OS X and) Tj
/F189 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21 the Mac operating system.) Tj
/F190 18.94 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(22 And in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act) Tj
/F189 11.41 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23 allegations, paragraph 46, we allege that Psystar admits that) Tj
/F189 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 Mac OS X, again without limitation on the version, normally) Tj
/F189 11.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25 will not run on non-Apple-labeled computers. But Psystar has) Tj
/F188 9.50 Tf
160.32 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF CJCFCCJCJ) Tj
/F189 8.10 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CJorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F188 10.49 Tf
45.84 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
150 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 328 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3`3l-`D%<%=h<;^=D[[/4Cqٶz%_Nb5XtKCK
Vr1TuI.+#r)=
endstream
endobj
151 0 obj
<<
/XObject 329 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 330 0 R
>>
endobj
152 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 331 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
153 0 obj
<<
/Length 332 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im194 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F195 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
501.60 740.64 TD
(27) Tj
/F196 11.40 Tf
-416.40 -40.80 TD
(1 come up with technology to allow it to run on Psystar) Tj
/F196 11.63 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 computers.) Tj
/F196 12.98 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 In certain respects, Your Honor, it i S as though there) Tj
/F196 11.40 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 were an infringement action pending in this court in which a) Tj
/F196 11.38 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 publisher, such as the Rudder Group, alleged infringement of) Tj
/F196 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 the copyright on the treatise Federal Civil Procedure Before) Tj
/F196 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7 Trial by Judges Schwarzer and Taschima, and then 3,000 miles) Tj
/F196 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 away the infringer filed an action saying, "We want declaratory) Tj
/F196 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9 relief that we do not infringe the copyright on the 2009) Tj
/F197 15.30 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 update.") Tj
/F197 18.38 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(11 Version 10.6, Snow Leopard, is written on top of) Tj
/F196 11.23 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 Version 10.5. You can i t run Snow Leopard without having) Tj
/F196 11.56 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 Leopard. And the copyrights to Mac OS X cover the subsequent) Tj
/F197 16.02 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 versions, as well.) Tj
/F195 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
/F196 11.69 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: I understand the background. But this is) Tj
/F196 11.60 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(16 not a motion. This is just a status conference.) Tj
/F195 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F195 14.74 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Yes.) Tj
/F195 11.52 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F196 11.71 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: So what is your point? Why did you want) Tj
/F196 11.51 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(19 a status conference?) Tj
/F195 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F197 16.84 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: First of all, to alert the Court to) Tj
/F196 11.65 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(21 this issue. And, secondly, to request a couple of) Tj
/F197 17.35 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 possibilities.) Tj
/F195 20.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 One is that we reopea discovery for 30 days, so that) Tj
/F196 11.26 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24 Apple can get the source code for, apparently, Psystar' s new) Tj
/F196 11.43 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25 product, and we take a step back.) Tj
/F195 10.21 Tf
159.60 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff SuffivanJ CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F196 8.10 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(offf CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F196 7.80 Tf
46.08 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
154 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 333 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3b3l-`D%<%=h<;^=D[[8_h{āf܊.Ŝk ,3:.b-\+#r?
endstream
endobj
155 0 obj
<<
/XObject 334 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 335 0 R
>>
endobj
156 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 336 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
157 0 obj
<<
/Length 337 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im201 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F202 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
502.32 740.40 TD
(28) Tj
/F202 5.00 Tf
-327.84 -10.56 TD
(.) Tj
/F202 9.60 Tf
-88.80 -29.52 TD
(1) Tj
/F203 11.49 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(This relates to what Ms. Chung said earlier. On) Tj
/F203 11.39 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(2 Friday of last week, seven days ago, Psystar announced that it) Tj
/F203 11.58 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 was selling a computer that runs with Snow Leopard. We have) Tj
/F203 11.41 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 not seen the source code for that technology, but we believe) Tj
/F203 11.35 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 that it is subsumed within the allegations in our complaint.) Tj
/F202 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6) Tj
/F203 11.49 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(Consequently, we suggest as follows: That the) Tj
/F203 11.01 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(7 parties - - that the Court allow discovery for another 30 days i) Tj
/F203 11.17 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(8 that Psystar turn over the source code for its new product i) Tj
/F203 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9 that we be allowed to ask Mr. Pedraza what he didi and Apple) Tj
/F203 11.41 Tf
-6.96 -24.72 TD
(10 will make Mr. Vidrine available to testify about any changes in) Tj
/F203 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 the technological protection measure, so that those issues can) Tj
/F203 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12 be finally resolved at the trial in January.) Tj
/F204 18.22 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 Beyond that, we will, of course, make a motion either) Tj
/F203 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 in this court to stay the proceedings in Florida, or in the) Tj
/F203 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 Florida court to transfer them here, or both.) Tj
/F204 19.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 But in the short run, in order to make this as) Tj
/F203 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 efficient as possible, our request is that the Court allow us) Tj
/F203 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18 to take the small amount of discovery specifically related to) Tj
/F203 11.53 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(19 the newest product, released seven days ago. And, in exchange,) Tj
/F203 11.42 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 we will offer to make Mr. Vidrine available for anything that) Tj
/F203 11.39 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 relates to the changes as between Leopard and Snow Leopard.) Tj
/F202 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F204 13.49 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Mr. Camara, what do you say?) Tj
/F202 11.52 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F202 16.21 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(MR. CARA: Your Honor, the difference between the) Tj
/F203 11.46 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(24 Florida case and this case is that Florida relates to Snow) Tj
/F203 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25 Leopard, this to Leopard. And that changes the evidence that) Tj
/F202 10.29 Tf
159.84 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF ~ CCJCJ) Tj
/F203 8.10 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F203 7.83 Tf
46.08 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
158 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 338 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z̮k3l-`D%<%=h<;.z"$pP"/mW+s>3[3:Ja-+#s#A
endstream
endobj
159 0 obj
<<
/XObject 339 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 340 0 R
>>
endobj
160 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 341 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
161 0 obj
<<
/Length 342 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im208 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F209 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
502.32 740.64 TD
(29) Tj
/F210 11.43 Tf
-417.12 -40.32 TD
(1 is at issue in both cases.) Tj
/F210 13.65 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 The technological protection mechanism that Apple) Tj
/F210 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3 uses in Snow Leopard is different from the mechanism that it) Tj
/F210 11.42 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 uses in Leopard, which means the evidence for the circumvention) Tj
/F210 11.40 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 claims, the DMCA claims and the copyright infringement claims) Tj
0.24 -24.96 TD
(6 will be different in Florida than here.) Tj
/F210 13.67 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 And the technique that Psystar uses to cause Snow) Tj
/F210 11.41 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(8 Leopard to run on non-Apple hardware is completely different in) Tj
/F210 11.61 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(9 Snow Leopard than in Leopard. So, again, the evidence is) Tj
/F211 15.97 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 completely different.) Tj
/F211 18.62 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 And if we look at the manner in which the parties --) Tj
/F210 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(12 or more specifically Apple has conducted discovery so far, we) Tj
/F210 11.42 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(13 see that they have carved out at every occasion Snow Leopard) Tj
/F209 17.52 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 from this case.) Tj
/F211 17.56 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 And here 11m going to describe deposition testimony.) Tj
/F210 11.07 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 I don i t know if you want to somehow move to close this to the) Tj
/F210 11.06 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 world, but I i m going to talk about AEO testimony, if you want) Tj
/F210 11.53 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18 to do anything.) Tj
/F209 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F209 13.51 Tf
93.12 0.48 TD
(MS. CHUNG: Yes.) Tj
/F209 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(20) Tj
/F209 14.32 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MS. SMITH: Yes.) Tj
/F209 12.00 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(21) Tj
/F209 15.47 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Apparently, Your Honor, we are going) Tj
/F210 11.45 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(22 to talk about the specifics of the technological protection) Tj
/F210 11.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 measurei and, therefore, we would request the courtroom be) Tj
/F209 17.47 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(24 disclosed.) Tj
/F209 11.76 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F210 11.51 Tf
93.84 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: These people in the audience here, are) Tj
/F211 9.86 Tf
66.00 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSuffivan, CSCF CJCFC~) Tj
/F210 8.12 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F210 7.89 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
162 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 343 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3k3l-`D%<%=h<;^D[[8[GͶ+vs>3[7:Vr|cWJs:
endstream
endobj
163 0 obj
<<
/XObject 344 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 345 0 R
>>
endobj
164 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 346 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
165 0 obj
<<
/Length 347 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im215 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F216 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
502.32 740.88 TD
(30) Tj
/F217 11.44 Tf
-416.64 -40.32 TD
(1 they members of the public, or what?) Tj
/F216 9.60 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F217 11.40 Tf
86.88 0.00 TD
(UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: Public San Francisco resident.) Tj
/F217 11.63 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(3 Non-reporter.) Tj
/F216 9.60 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F217 10.97 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Well, I don i t like to close the) Tj
/F217 11.67 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(5 courtroom.) Tj
/F216 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(6) Tj
/F217 11.23 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(Gi ve me a general statement. Why would you be) Tj
/F216 18.67 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(7 getting into this?) Tj
/F216 9.12 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F216 17.16 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(MR. CARA: I just want to quote portions of) Tj
/F217 11.39 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(9 deposition transcripts which are designated "Attorneys' Eyes) Tj
/F217 11.56 Tf
-6.72 -24.96 TD
(10 Only." Not for any technical details, but merely to show that) Tj
/F217 11.24 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 Apple has continually obj ected to all testimony about Snow) Tj
/F217 11.67 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 Leopard.) Tj
/F216 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F217 11.50 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Well, is that part true, that Apple) Tj
/F216 11.28 Tf
-93.60 -24.96 TD
(14) Tj
/F216 16.01 Tf
25.44 0.00 TD
(objected) Tj
/F216 16.05 Tf
61.68 0.00 TD
(to) Tj
/F216 15.34 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(testimony) Tj
/F216 12.73 Tf
67.68 0.24 TD
(on) Tj
/F216 11.59 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(Snow) Tj
/F216 13.92 Tf
33.84 0.24 TD
(Leopard?) Tj
/F216 11.28 Tf
-229.20 -25.20 TD
(15) Tj
/F216 10.10 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F216 13.21 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(GILLILAN:) Tj
/F216 11.90 Tf
80.88 0.24 TD
(No,) Tj
/F217 10.91 Tf
27.36 0.00 TD
(Your Honor.) Tj
/F216 11.04 Tf
-228.72 -25.20 TD
(16) Tj
/F216 14.99 Tf
94.08 0.24 TD
(In) Tj
/F216 17.29 Tf
20.40 0.00 TD
(fact,) Tj
/F216 13.69 Tf
40.80 0.00 TD
(I) Tj
/F216 13.86 Tf
12.72 0.00 TD
(have) Tj
/F216 16.13 Tf
34.08 0.00 TD
(deposition) Tj
/F216 15.34 Tf
74.88 0.00 TD
(testimony) Tj
/F216 14.37 Tf
67.68 0.24 TD
(about) Tj
/F216 11.70 Tf
40.32 0.00 TD
(Snow) Tj
/F216 11.28 Tf
-384.96 -25.44 TD
(17) Tj
/F216 14.19 Tf
25.44 0.24 TD
(Leopard) Tj
/F216 17.29 Tf
54.72 -.24 TD
(that) Tj
/F216 13.69 Tf
34.56 0.24 TD
(I) Tj
/F216 14.01 Tf
13.20 0.00 TD
(can) Tj
/F218 13.22 Tf
26.64 0.00 TD
(hand you.) Tj
/F216 11.28 Tf
-154.56 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F216 10.10 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(MR.) Tj
/F216 11.38 Tf
27.60 0.00 TD
(CAMRA:) Tj
/F216 11.99 Tf
60.24 0.24 TD
(And) Tj
/F216 13.69 Tf
28.56 0.00 TD
(I) Tj
/F217 11.07 Tf
13.20 0.00 TD
(can quote) Tj
/F217 11.16 Tf
67.68 0.00 TD
(deposition objections) Tj
/F216 11.52 Tf
-290.40 -25.20 TD
(19) Tj
/F217 10.65 Tf
25.92 0.00 TD
(from Ms.) Tj
/F216 14.09 Tf
61.20 0.00 TD
(Smith,) Tj
/F217 10.93 Tf
48.00 0.00 TD
(if you) Tj
/F216 13.45 Tf
46.32 0.24 TD
(would) Tj
/F216 17.42 Tf
41.52 0.00 TD
(like.) Tj
/F216 11.76 Tf
-223.20 -25.20 TD
(20) Tj
/F217 11.48 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Well, I can't resolve this part today, no) Tj
/F217 11.50 Tf
-93.84 -24.96 TD
(21 matter what you quote.) Tj
/F216 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F217 11.69 Tf
94.32 0.00 TD
(So, all right. I understand. I'm not ruling against) Tj
/F217 11.61 Tf
-94.32 -24.96 TD
(23 you or for you on this point, Mr. Camara. I want to understand) Tj
/F217 11.53 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24 your full argument.) Tj
/F216 11.76 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(25) Tj
/F218 15.34 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Sure. So this case, we think the) Tj
/F218 9.74 Tf
66.48 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F217 8.35 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - V.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F217 7.86 Tf
45.60 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
166 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 348 0 R
>>
stream
x%ȹ0E~PxL:VQQDADwEEb0ϞeД#gg9Hm4_b5|x%0b˥ubL>}TAy>PE?o3
endstream
endobj
167 0 obj
<<
/XObject 349 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 350 0 R
>>
endobj
168 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 351 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
169 0 obj
<<
/Length 352 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im222 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F223 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
502.80 741.12 TD
(31) Tj
/F224 11.31 Tf
-416.40 -39.84 TD
(1 discovery has been fully completed with respect to Leopard,) Tj
/F224 11.03 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 with respect to whether Psystar i s business practices throughout) Tj
/F224 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(3 its inception until the time it switched from Leopard to Snow) Tj
/F224 11.53 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 Leopard are legal or not. That discovery as been conducted.) Tj
/F224 11.75 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 Fact discovery is closed. We are now in expert discovery. And) Tj
/F224 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 we have a schedule that will work for both sides to) Tj
/F224 11.03 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7 expeditiously resolve the legality of Psystar i s business up) Tj
/F224 11.38 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(8 until Snow Leopard, by trial in January.) Tj
/F224 13.65 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(9 We don't want to ups~t that by going into all new) Tj
/F224 11.39 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 fact discovery about the manner in which Psystar circumvents or) Tj
/F224 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 does not circumvent Snow Leopard, and about the nature of the) Tj
/F224 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 technological protection measures that Apple uses in Snow) Tj
/F224 11.64 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 Leopard.) Tj
/F223 20.50 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 If Apple had wanted to raise those claims, it could) Tj
/F224 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 have done so by expressly supplementing to include Snow Leopard) Tj
/F224 11.65 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 when it came out. It could have done so, again, by) Tj
/F223 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F224 11.80 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Help me understand. When did Snow) Tj
/F224 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(18 Leopard 10.6 come out?) Tj
/F223 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F225 15.09 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: I believe it was August 28th, which) Tj
/F225 17.95 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(20 is) Tj
/F223 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21) Tj
/F224 11.67 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Of this year?) Tj
/F223 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F225 16.04 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(MR. CARA: Of this year.) Tj
/F223 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F225 13.34 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: August 28th.) Tj
/F223 11.52 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(24) Tj
/F224 11.80 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Wnich is after the close of fact) Tj
/F223 17.71 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(25 discovery in this case.) Tj
/F225 9.84 Tf
159.60 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSuffivan, CSCF CJCFC~) Tj
/F224 8.36 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - VS. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F223 10.56 Tf
45.60 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
170 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 353 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~R;3KI6іB0X
`k- -.#K3ݚsS
;]6 SƱdžb}S'F@% p75
endstream
endobj
171 0 obj
<<
/XObject 354 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 355 0 R
>>
endobj
172 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 356 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
173 0 obj
<<
/Length 357 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im229 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F230 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
503.28 741.12 TD
(32) Tj
/F230 9.60 Tf
-416.88 -40.32 TD
(1) Tj
/F231 11.49 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: And when did your company make this) Tj
/F231 11.48 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(2 announcement about your product?) Tj
/F230 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F231 12.04 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: It was last week. I donlt remember) Tj
/F231 11.44 Tf
-86.16 -25.20 TD
(4 precisely which day last week.) Tj
/F230 9.60 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F231 11.54 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: And just tell me, what did your) Tj
/F231 11.60 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(6 announcement say?) Tj
/F230 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(7) Tj
/F231 11.74 Tf
85.92 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: We announced we are offering for sale) Tj
/F231 11.41 Tf
-85.68 -24.96 TD
(8 computers running Snow Leopard.) Tj
/F230 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(9) Tj
/F232 12.53 Tf
86.16 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Okay.) Tj
/F230 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -25.20 TD
(10) Tj
/F232 14.19 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: So we would propose to have those issues) Tj
/F231 11.41 Tf
-92.64 -24.96 TD
(11 be litigated in the Florida court.) Tj
/F232 19.43 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 The Florida court, of course, will be free to give) Tj
/F231 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(13 any preclusive effect that is appropriate to the decision of) Tj
/F231 11.46 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(14 this court in January.) Tj
/F230 20.46 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(15 So to the extent the issues are the same - - we think) Tj
/F231 11.35 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 they are not the same, but to the extent they are the same,) Tj
/F231 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 Mr. Gilliland will be able to make preclusion motions in the) Tj
/F232 16.55 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 federal court in Florida.) Tj
/F232 18.26 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19 Meanwhile, we will get an expeditious ruling from the) Tj
/F231 11.41 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20 jury, and from this Court on summary judgment, about the legal) Tj
/F230 17.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 issues involved in Psystarl s business from its inception until) Tj
/F231 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22 a week ago, which is what discovery has been about in this case) Tj
/F232 17.38 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 to this point.) Tj
/F230 11.52 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F231 11.54 Tf
93.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Mr. Gilliland, what do you now say in) Tj
/F231 11.80 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(25 response?) Tj
/F232 10.63 Tf
160.08 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF ~ C~) Tj
/F231 7.65 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(Offiaf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F231 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
174 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 358 0 R
>>
stream
x%ȹ@}-ybKI&і@0"q~I,AIb0ώKo
QNꑥ@m_ǦKqn?C{qo"QI|hp}~p7
endstream
endobj
175 0 obj
<<
/XObject 359 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 360 0 R
>>
endobj
176 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 361 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
177 0 obj
<<
/Length 362 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im236 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F237 11.04 Tf
100 Tz
503.76 740.88 TD
(33) Tj
/F237 9.60 Tf
-417.12 -40.32 TD
(1) Tj
/F237 15.70 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: That nothing could possibly be more) Tj
/F238 11.37 Tf
-86.16 -25.20 TD
(2 inefficient than what Mr. Camara has just proposed.) Tj
/F237 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F238 11.47 Tf
86.40 0.24 TD
(This Court has studied these issues deeply. We have) Tj
/F238 11.66 Tf
-86.64 -25.20 TD
(4 a trial coming up in January. It involves all the) Tj
/F238 11.39 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(5 technological protection measures in Leopard.) Tj
/F238 13.44 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 And if there are any modest changes in Snow Leopard,) Tj
/F238 11.06 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7 let i s just find out what they are right now, and include them) Tj
/F238 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 in the trial in January.) Tj
/F238 13.72 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(9 Why in the world would we start allover again with a) Tj
/F238 11.41 Tf
-6.96 -24.96 TD
(10 whole new court 3,000 miles away, when this court and the) Tj
/F238 11.46 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 parties are primed and ready to go?) Tj
/F237 11.28 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(12) Tj
/F239 14.26 Tf
92.64 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Your Honor, the change - - the new) Tj
/F238 11.37 Tf
-92.64 -25.20 TD
(13 discovery that would have to be taken is not trivial.) Tj
/F239 17.85 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14 For example, Mr. Vidrine, who the Court has already) Tj
/F238 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 ordered will not be able to testify, is the person who is) Tj
/F239 15.21 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 charged with designing the new technological protection) Tj
/F238 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 measures for Snow Leopard.) Tj
/F238 13.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(18 If Apple thought Snow Leopard was covered by this) Tj
/F238 11.62 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(19 case, they should have disclosed Mr. Vidrine. He is the guy) Tj
/F238 11.61 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 who designed the protection measures. We would have to take) Tj
/F238 11.51 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 his deposition.) Tj
/F237 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
/F238 11.75 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Well, I understand that. Possibly -- I'm) Tj
/F238 11.44 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(23 not saying it would be, but possibly this new development which) Tj
/F238 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24 just occurred would constitute, quote, substantial) Tj
/F238 11.36 Tf
0.24 -25.20 TD
(25 justification for a revised disclosure, even at this late date,) Tj
/F239 9.70 Tf
160.08 -25.92 TD
('1tlierine CFoive\(\( Suffivan, CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F238 8.11 Tf
11.04 -10.80 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F238 7.83 Tf
45.84 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
178 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 363 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~R;KI6іB0X
`k
q- -.Gf-v+sS
[6 Sc
։bzL-4OJq19
endstream
endobj
179 0 obj
<<
/XObject 364 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 365 0 R
>>
endobj
180 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 366 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
181 0 obj
<<
/Length 367 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im243 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F244 11.28 Tf
100 Tz
504.48 740.40 TD
(34) Tj
/F245 11.57 Tf
-417.12 -39.36 TD
(1 and to add Mr. Vidrine. And then he would be made available) Tj
/F245 11.60 Tf
-.48 -24.96 TD
(2 and so forth.) Tj
/F244 9.12 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F245 11.42 Tf
86.88 0.00 TD
(Look, here is the answer to this. The answer is:) Tj
/F245 10.78 Tf
-87.36 -24.96 TD
(4 You i ve got to bring a motion.) Tj
/F244 9.60 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F245 11.47 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(Right now I'm not going to open discovery. We have a) Tj
/F245 11.39 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(6 trial. But if you want to bring a formal motion to - - there's) Tj
0.00 -24.72 TD
(7 no way we could have a trial in January if we do what you want) Tj
/F245 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 to do, because you then are thinking, "Oh, that judge has) Tj
/F245 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(9 nothing to do but work on my case.") Tj
/F244 11.52 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10) Tj
/F245 11.72 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(That's not true. I've got 400 cases. And you would) Tj
/F245 11.43 Tf
-93.36 -24.72 TD
(11 then be taking a month of my time away to work on summary) Tj
/F244 17.12 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 judgment, and so forth, and expect me to get this case ready) Tj
/F245 11.48 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13 for trial by January.) Tj
/F244 20.51 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(14 If you want to give up your trial date in January and) Tj
/F245 11.05 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 say, "Okay, let i s litigate the issue of Snow Leopard and 10.6) Tj
/F245 11.41 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 and the new product by the defendant," the Court would consider) Tj
/F246 17.05 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17 that.) Tj
/F244 20.67 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(18 I can see relevance, of course, to the - - I i d also be) Tj
/F245 11.41 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(19 concerned, if it is true -- I don't know that it's true that) Tj
/F245 11.07 Tf
-.24 -24.72 TD
(20 there i s been stonewalling by Apple on the issue of Snow) Tj
/F245 11.42 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(21 Leopard, so that it would be unfair to allow you to enlarge the) Tj
/F244 17.70 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(22 pleadings. I'm not saying it has been stonewalling, but that's) Tj
/F245 11.50 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(23 what you want to show me.) Tj
/F244 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F245 11.53 Tf
93.36 -.24 TD
(And so you can make that submission. And then the) Tj
/F246 15.09 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(25 Court would have to decide whether to enlarge the discovery) Tj
/F246 10.70 Tf
160.32 -26.40 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvan, CSCF ~ C~) Tj
/F244 11.26 Tf
11.28 -10.80 TD
(Offia\( CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F245 7.80 Tf
45.84 -15.36 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
182 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 368 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;|RM%H|~$砤m1gKک8NW#K3u%b.
TxƱr1\QL
4_Jq;
endstream
endobj
183 0 obj
<<
/XObject 369 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 370 0 R
>>
endobj
184 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 371 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
185 0 obj
<<
/Length 372 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im250 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F251 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
503.52 740.40 TD
(35) Tj
/F252 11.41 Tf
-417.36 -40.56 TD
(1 period and redo the trial schedule.) Tj
/F251 10.08 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F252 11.53 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(So I'm not ruling yes or no. This is too) Tj
/F252 11.42 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(3 complicated, too many nuances for m to give you an answer off) Tj
/F251 18.20 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 the top of my head. I think this has got to be briefed.) Tj
/F252 13.52 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 In the meantime, if the Court in Florida is going to) Tj
/F252 11.40 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 have to make a ruling on whether to go forward with that case) Tj
/F252 11.24 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7 or transfer it, or whatever - - and I will say for the record) Tj
/F253 15.92 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8 I'm happy for that case to be transferred here. I i m not) Tj
/F252 11.78 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(9 resisting that. 11m not inviting it, either. I'm just saying) Tj
/F252 11.41 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 it would be a plausible thing for the judge there to say the) Tj
/F251 17.45 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 case ought to be transferred here.) Tj
/F251 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12) Tj
/F252 11.50 Tf
93.36 0.00 TD
(Or maybe it will be an MDL, In Re Snow Leopard. In) Tj
/F252 11.76 Tf
-93.36 -24.96 TD
(13 Re Snow Leopard litigation. I can just see that now. Maybe it) Tj
/F252 11.06 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(14 will go to Florida because then I won i t have to do any more) Tj
/F251 17.09 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 work on this case.) Tj
/F251 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F252 11.07 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(Look, that's the best I can do for you. You I re going) Tj
/F252 11.61 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(17 to have to bring a formal motion. But, in the meantime, the) Tj
/F252 11.45 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(18 case schedule stands.) Tj
/F251 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F253 15.23 Tf
92.88 0.48 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Do you mind if we bring that motion) Tj
/F252 11.47 Tf
-93.12 -25.44 TD
(20 on less than 35 days notice, Your Honor?) Tj
/F251 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21) Tj
/F252 11.79 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: I think you should. So your opening) Tj
/F252 11.53 Tf
-93.60 -25.20 TD
(22 motion, when can you do it?) Tj
/F251 11.52 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
/F251 15.23 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: One week from today, Your Honor --) Tj
/F252 11.43 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(24 yes, we can do it Friday of next week.) Tj
/F251 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F252 11.23 Tf
93.60 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: All right. That i s going to be the 11th.) Tj
/F251 9.53 Tf
66.24 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweff Suffivan, CSCF CJCFCCJCJ) Tj
/F252 8.37 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - V.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F252 7.83 Tf
46.32 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
186 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 373 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ@~Z;3,`3l-`D%<=h<;eElIoP<6+%v9V c-}K.r[bTr+=
endstream
endobj
187 0 obj
<<
/XObject 374 0 R
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB /ImageC /ImageI]
/Font 375 0 R
>>
endobj
188 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 376 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
189 0 obj
<<
/Length 377 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im257 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F258 11.52 Tf
100 Tz
503.28 741.36 TD
(36) Tj
/F259 11.61 Tf
-417.36 -40.56 TD
(1 Then I will give one week for the reply, on the 18th. Then) Tj
/F259 11.36 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(2 any -- 11m sorry, for the opposition, is what i meant to say.) Tj
/F259 11.45 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(3 The reply will be the 21st.) Tj
/F259 13.43 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(4 That means that you will be working over the weekend.) Tj
/F259 13.36 Tf
0.48 -24.96 TD
(5 MR. GILLILAN: That won i t be the first time we Ive) Tj
/F259 11.70 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(6 done that in this case. Right, Mr. Camara?) Tj
/F258 9.60 Tf
0.24 -24.72 TD
(7) Tj
/F260 14.48 Tf
86.16 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Not surprised.) Tj
/F258 9.12 Tf
-86.16 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F259 11.48 Tf
86.64 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: i am surprised to hear that.) Tj
/F258 9.12 Tf
-86.40 -25.20 TD
(9) Tj
/F259 11.46 Tf
85.92 0.24 TD
(All right. 9/24 will be the argument, at 8:00 a.m.) Tj
/F258 11.52 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(10) Tj
/F258 14.92 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Thank you very much, Your Honor.) Tj
/F258 11.76 Tf
-93.12 -24.96 TD
(11) Tj
/F259 11.46 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: Thatls about 20 days, instead of 35.) Tj
/F258 11.04 Tf
-93.12 -25.20 TD
(12) Tj
/F260 15.28 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Appreciate that.) Tj
/F258 11.04 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F258 14.56 Tf
92.88 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Thank you, Your Honor.) Tj
/F260 18.28 Tf
-92.88 -24.96 TD
(14 There is one more outstanding issue, which is that) Tj
/F259 11.38 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(15 motion with supplemental briefing that was done last week,) Tj
/F258 16.22 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16 about compelling testimony on damages, i don i t know if the) Tj
/F259 12.15 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(17 Court) Tj
/F258 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F259 11.75 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(THE COURT: That's still pending. What about it?) Tj
/F258 11.52 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(19) Tj
/F260 15.11 Tf
93.12 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: i don't know if the Court wan ted to take) Tj
/F259 11.46 Tf
-93.36 -25.20 TD
(20 any further argument on that.) Tj
/F258 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21) Tj
/F259 11.27 Tf
93.84 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: i don i t want any more argument. i) Tj
/F259 11.63 Tf
-93.84 -24.96 TD
(22 understand that issue. i think we now have everything we're) Tj
/F259 11.81 Tf
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23 supposed to have on that. Don't we?) Tj
/F259 15.58 Tf
0.24 -24.96 TD
(24 MR. GILLILAN: Yes, Your Honor.) Tj
/F258 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F258 14.53 Tf
93.36 0.24 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Yes, Your Honor.) Tj
/F260 9.78 Tf
66.96 -26.16 TD
('1tlierine CFoweffSuffivanJ CSCF ~CCJCJ) Tj
/F259 8.12 Tf
11.04 -11.04 TD
(Offf CRorter - 'US. CDtrict Court) Tj
/F259 7.86 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
190 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 378 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
192 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 381 0 R
>>
stream
x+ |
endstream
endobj
193 0 obj
<<
/Length 382 0 R
>>
stream
q
q
612.00 0.00 0.00 792.00 0.00 0.00 cm
0.00 0.00 0.00 rg
/Im264 Do Q
Q q
BT
3 Tr
/F265 11.76 Tf
100 Tz
504.00 741.12 TD
(37) Tj
/F265 9.60 Tf
-417.36 -39.60 TD
(1) Tj
/F266 11.70 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: Okay. I think we are at the end.) Tj
/F265 9.60 Tf
-87.12 -24.96 TD
(2) Tj
/F265 14.53 Tf
86.64 0.00 TD
(MR. CAMRA: Thank you, Your Honor.) Tj
/F265 9.12 Tf
-86.40 -24.96 TD
(3) Tj
/F267 15.07 Tf
86.40 0.00 TD
(MR. GILLILAN: Thank you for your time.) Tj
/F265 9.60 Tf
-86.64 -24.96 TD
(4) Tj
/F267 13.13 Tf
87.12 0.00 TD
(THE COURT: You are most welcome.) Tj
/F265 9.60 Tf
-86.88 -24.96 TD
(5) Tj
/F266 11.07 Tf
89.52 -.96 TD
(\(At 10:52 a.m. the proceedings were adjourned.\)) Tj
/F265 9.12 Tf
-89.28 -24.00 TD
(6) Tj
/F267 13.62 Tf
209.52 0.00 TD
(- -000--) Tj
/F265 9.12 Tf
-209.52 -24.72 TD
(7) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(8) Tj
/F265 9.60 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(9) Tj
/F266 20.32 Tf
-6.72 -24.72 TD
(10 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER) Tj
/F265 21.40 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(11 I certify that the foregoing is a correct transcript) Tj
/F265 17.08 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(12 from the record of proceedings in the above-entitled matter.) Tj
/F265 11.04 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(13) Tj
/F265 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(14) Tj
/F265 10.68 Tf
25.20 0.00 TD
(DATE:) Tj
/F265 11.28 Tf
-25.20 -24.72 TD
(15) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(16) Tj
/F265 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(17) Tj
/F265 11.28 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(18) Tj
/F265 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(19) Tj
/F265 11.76 Tf
-.24 -24.96 TD
(20) Tj
/F265 12.00 Tf
0.00 -24.72 TD
(21) Tj
/F265 11.52 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(22) Tj
0.00 -25.20 TD
(23) Tj
0.00 -24.96 TD
(24) Tj
/F265 11.76 Tf
0.00 -24.96 TD
(25) Tj
/F266 11.23 Tf
80.16 274.32 TD
(Friday, September 4, 2009) Tj
/F266 11.27 Tf
61.44 -37.44 TD
(sib Katherine Powell Sullivan) Tj
/F266 11.30 Tf
-58.08 -37.20 TD
(Katherine Powell Sullivan, CSR #5812, RPR, CRR) Tj
/F267 14.17 Tf
94.56 -12.48 TD
(U. S. Court Reporter) Tj
/F267 10.79 Tf
-18.24 -213.60 TD
('1tlierine CFowef\( Su\(fvanJ CSCF ~C~) Tj
/F266 8.13 Tf
11.28 -11.04 TD
(Off\( CRorter - 'U.s CDtrict Court) Tj
/F265 10.56 Tf
46.08 -15.12 TD
(\(415\) 794-6659) Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
194 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Length 383 0 R
>>
stream
x%Ȼ0>
endobj
196 0 obj
10
endobj
197 0 obj
591
endobj
198 0 obj
124
endobj
199 0 obj
<<
/Im7 386 0 R
>>
endobj
200 0 obj
<<
/F8 387 0 R
/Xi0 388 0 R
>>
endobj
201 0 obj
10
endobj
202 0 obj
2353
endobj
203 0 obj
123
endobj
204 0 obj
<<
/Im12 389 0 R
>>
endobj
205 0 obj
<<
/F15 390 0 R
/F13 391 0 R
/Xi1 388 0 R
/F14 392 0 R
>>
endobj
206 0 obj
10
endobj
207 0 obj
2748
endobj
208 0 obj
123
endobj
209 0 obj
<<
/Im19 393 0 R
>>
endobj
210 0 obj
<<
/F20 394 0 R
/Xi2 388 0 R
/F21 395 0 R
/F22 396 0 R
>>
endobj
211 0 obj
10
endobj
212 0 obj
3476
endobj
213 0 obj
123
endobj
214 0 obj
<<
/Im26 397 0 R
>>
endobj
215 0 obj
<<
/F29 398 0 R
/F28 399 0 R
/Xi3 388 0 R
/F27 400 0 R
>>
endobj
216 0 obj
10
endobj
217 0 obj
2797
endobj
218 0 obj
123
endobj
219 0 obj
<<
/Im33 401 0 R
>>
endobj
220 0 obj
<<
/Xi4 388 0 R
/F35 402 0 R
/F34 403 0 R
/F36 404 0 R
>>
endobj
221 0 obj
10
endobj
222 0 obj
3928
endobj
223 0 obj
123
endobj
224 0 obj
<<
/Im40 405 0 R
>>
endobj
225 0 obj
<<
/F43 406 0 R
/F42 407 0 R
/F41 408 0 R
/Xi5 388 0 R
>>
endobj
226 0 obj
10
endobj
227 0 obj
2681
endobj
228 0 obj
123
endobj
229 0 obj
<<
/Im47 409 0 R
>>
endobj
230 0 obj
<<
/F48 410 0 R
/Xi6 388 0 R
/F49 411 0 R
/F50 412 0 R
>>
endobj
231 0 obj
10
endobj
232 0 obj
4404
endobj
233 0 obj
123
endobj
234 0 obj
<<
/Im54 413 0 R
>>
endobj
235 0 obj
<<
/F57 414 0 R
/F56 415 0 R
/F55 416 0 R
/Xi7 388 0 R
>>
endobj
236 0 obj
10
endobj
237 0 obj
2700
endobj
238 0 obj
123
endobj
239 0 obj
<<
/Im61 417 0 R
>>
endobj
240 0 obj
<<
/F64 418 0 R
/F62 419 0 R
/Xi8 388 0 R
/F63 420 0 R
>>
endobj
241 0 obj
10
endobj
242 0 obj
2785
endobj
243 0 obj
123
endobj
244 0 obj
<<
/Im68 421 0 R
>>
endobj
245 0 obj
<<
/Xi9 388 0 R
/F70 422 0 R
/F69 423 0 R
/F71 424 0 R
>>
endobj
246 0 obj
10
endobj
247 0 obj
2743
endobj
248 0 obj
124
endobj
249 0 obj
<<
/Im75 425 0 R
>>
endobj
250 0 obj
<<
/F77 426 0 R
/Xi10 388 0 R
/F78 427 0 R
/F76 428 0 R
>>
endobj
251 0 obj
10
endobj
252 0 obj
2770
endobj
253 0 obj
125
endobj
254 0 obj
<<
/Im82 429 0 R
>>
endobj
255 0 obj
<<
/F85 430 0 R
/F83 431 0 R
/Xi11 388 0 R
/F84 432 0 R
>>
endobj
256 0 obj
10
endobj
257 0 obj
2711
endobj
258 0 obj
125
endobj
259 0 obj
<<
/Im89 433 0 R
>>
endobj
260 0 obj
<<
/F90 434 0 R
/F91 435 0 R
/Xi12 388 0 R
/F92 436 0 R
>>
endobj
261 0 obj
10
endobj
262 0 obj
2634
endobj
263 0 obj
124
endobj
264 0 obj
<<
/Im96 437 0 R
>>
endobj
265 0 obj
<<
/Xi13 388 0 R
/F99 438 0 R
/F97 439 0 R
/F98 440 0 R
>>
endobj
266 0 obj
10
endobj
267 0 obj
3025
endobj
268 0 obj
123
endobj
269 0 obj
<<
/Im103 441 0 R
>>
endobj
270 0 obj
<<
/F105 442 0 R
/Xi14 388 0 R
/F104 443 0 R
/F106 444 0 R
>>
endobj
271 0 obj
10
endobj
272 0 obj
2830
endobj
273 0 obj
124
endobj
274 0 obj
<<
/Im110 445 0 R
>>
endobj
275 0 obj
<<
/Xi15 388 0 R
/F112 446 0 R
/F113 447 0 R
/F111 448 0 R
>>
endobj
276 0 obj
10
endobj
277 0 obj
2897
endobj
278 0 obj
124
endobj
279 0 obj
<<
/Im117 449 0 R
>>
endobj
280 0 obj
<<
/Xi16 388 0 R
/F120 450 0 R
/F119 451 0 R
/F118 452 0 R
>>
endobj
281 0 obj
10
endobj
282 0 obj
2826
endobj
283 0 obj
124
endobj
284 0 obj
<<
/Im124 453 0 R
>>
endobj
285 0 obj
<<
/F127 454 0 R
/F125 455 0 R
/Xi17 388 0 R
/F126 456 0 R
>>
endobj
286 0 obj
10
endobj
287 0 obj
2796
endobj
288 0 obj
124
endobj
289 0 obj
<<
/Im131 457 0 R
>>
endobj
290 0 obj
<<
/F134 458 0 R
/F132 459 0 R
/F133 460 0 R
/Xi18 388 0 R
>>
endobj
291 0 obj
10
endobj
292 0 obj
2936
endobj
293 0 obj
124
endobj
294 0 obj
<<
/Im138 461 0 R
>>
endobj
295 0 obj
<<
/F141 462 0 R
/Xi19 388 0 R
/F139 463 0 R
/F140 464 0 R
>>
endobj
296 0 obj
10
endobj
297 0 obj
2941
endobj
298 0 obj
124
endobj
299 0 obj
<<
/Im145 465 0 R
>>
endobj
300 0 obj
<<
/F147 466 0 R
/Xi20 388 0 R
/F148 467 0 R
/F146 468 0 R
>>
endobj
301 0 obj
10
endobj
302 0 obj
5172
endobj
303 0 obj
123
endobj
304 0 obj
<<
/Im152 469 0 R
>>
endobj
305 0 obj
<<
/F154 470 0 R
/Xi21 388 0 R
/F155 471 0 R
/F153 472 0 R
>>
endobj
306 0 obj
10
endobj
307 0 obj
2769
endobj
308 0 obj
123
endobj
309 0 obj
<<
/Im159 473 0 R
>>
endobj
310 0 obj
<<
/F161 474 0 R
/Xi22 388 0 R
/F160 475 0 R
/F162 476 0 R
>>
endobj
311 0 obj
10
endobj
312 0 obj
5591
endobj
313 0 obj
125
endobj
314 0 obj
<<
/Im166 477 0 R
>>
endobj
315 0 obj
<<
/F167 478 0 R
/Xi23 388 0 R
/F169 479 0 R
/F168 480 0 R
>>
endobj
316 0 obj
10
endobj
317 0 obj
2856
endobj
318 0 obj
123
endobj
319 0 obj
<<
/Im173 481 0 R
>>
endobj
320 0 obj
<<
/Xi24 388 0 R
/F175 482 0 R
/F176 483 0 R
/F174 484 0 R
>>
endobj
321 0 obj
10
endobj
322 0 obj
2784
endobj
323 0 obj
124
endobj
324 0 obj
<<
/Im180 485 0 R
>>
endobj
325 0 obj
<<
/F182 486 0 R
/Xi25 388 0 R
/F181 487 0 R
/F183 488 0 R
>>
endobj
326 0 obj
10
endobj
327 0 obj
2769
endobj
328 0 obj
124
endobj
329 0 obj
<<
/Im187 489 0 R
>>
endobj
330 0 obj
<<
/Xi26 388 0 R
/F188 490 0 R
/F189 491 0 R
/F190 492 0 R
>>
endobj
331 0 obj
10
endobj
332 0 obj
2672
endobj
333 0 obj
124
endobj
334 0 obj
<<
/Im194 493 0 R
>>
endobj
335 0 obj
<<
/F195 494 0 R
/F197 495 0 R
/Xi27 388 0 R
/F196 496 0 R
>>
endobj
336 0 obj
10
endobj
337 0 obj
2997
endobj
338 0 obj
124
endobj
339 0 obj
<<
/Im201 497 0 R
>>
endobj
340 0 obj
<<
/F203 498 0 R
/Xi28 388 0 R
/F204 499 0 R
/F202 500 0 R
>>
endobj
341 0 obj
10
endobj
342 0 obj
2662
endobj
343 0 obj
124
endobj
344 0 obj
<<
/Im208 501 0 R
>>
endobj
345 0 obj
<<
/F211 502 0 R
/F209 503 0 R
/F210 504 0 R
/Xi29 388 0 R
>>
endobj
346 0 obj
10
endobj
347 0 obj
3950
endobj
348 0 obj
124
endobj
349 0 obj
<<
/Im215 505 0 R
>>
endobj
350 0 obj
<<
/F218 506 0 R
/Xi30 388 0 R
/F217 507 0 R
/F216 508 0 R
>>
endobj
351 0 obj
10
endobj
352 0 obj
2744
endobj
353 0 obj
124
endobj
354 0 obj
<<
/Im222 509 0 R
>>
endobj
355 0 obj
<<
/Xi31 388 0 R
/F224 510 0 R
/F223 511 0 R
/F225 512 0 R
>>
endobj
356 0 obj
10
endobj
357 0 obj
2703
endobj
358 0 obj
122
endobj
359 0 obj
<<
/Im229 513 0 R
>>
endobj
360 0 obj
<<
/F232 514 0 R
/F230 515 0 R
/Xi32 388 0 R
/F231 516 0 R
>>
endobj
361 0 obj
10
endobj
362 0 obj
2783
endobj
363 0 obj
124
endobj
364 0 obj
<<
/Im236 517 0 R
>>
endobj
365 0 obj
<<
/Xi33 388 0 R
/F237 518 0 R
/F239 519 0 R
/F238 520 0 R
>>
endobj
366 0 obj
10
endobj
367 0 obj
2766
endobj
368 0 obj
124
endobj
369 0 obj
<<
/Im243 521 0 R
>>
endobj
370 0 obj
<<
/F246 522 0 R
/F244 523 0 R
/Xi34 388 0 R
/F245 524 0 R
>>
endobj
371 0 obj
10
endobj
372 0 obj
2875
endobj
373 0 obj
124
endobj
374 0 obj
<<
/Im250 525 0 R
>>
endobj
375 0 obj
<<
/Xi35 388 0 R
/F251 526 0 R
/F253 527 0 R
/F252 528 0 R
>>
endobj
376 0 obj
10
endobj
377 0 obj
2883
endobj
378 0 obj
124
endobj
379 0 obj
<<
/Im257 529 0 R
>>
endobj
380 0 obj
<<
/F259 530 0 R
/F260 531 0 R
/Xi36 388 0 R
/F258 532 0 R
>>
endobj
381 0 obj
10
endobj
382 0 obj
2216
endobj
383 0 obj
124
endobj
384 0 obj
<<
/Im264 533 0 R
>>
endobj
385 0 obj
<<
/Xi37 388 0 R
/F266 534 0 R
/F265 535 0 R
/F267 536 0 R
>>
endobj
386 0 obj
<<
/eCpyDPIY 300
/Type /XObject
/BitsPerComponent 1
/Height 3300
/DecodeParms 537 0 R
/eCpyDPIX 300
/Subtype /Image
/ImageMask true
/Filter /CCITTFaxDecode
/Length 538 0 R
/eCpyColor [0 0 0]
/Name /Im7
/Decode [0 1]
/Width 2550
>>
stream
V^|2^?+[_i( 8Wj-?d4;n<@YS,Q0V?U46-[+Q
)^9gR-l?? 0"u-xQ55Nvd(e^>[b[&HEh菑#vGDtGDtGDq">GD|莈G\5i""""")js0̈""#탭?)oPDt
@ r)jh5MqAtCUj X_};~^-woQo^]iut믮[^{~կKA}uk%AJ /on!h^?þnۮk:i^{H7O_oIO7/7MZM%UVl%wU_Az|-oA58`'2Y*0GF4Ӡ4.Z"
˃J/tP9C9A9NTLR)-cw<eP2*A$9rn1宬#tGDtG莈/>G8!ph0
GDt#`AyWܡ膂(A0&uaGz
x)#8&DDDI| 0JC>' LSr4Awoi庀kW!";dA9hACq .Iհz
UpP:R( <0!
H=_ӫ~O}Է
2B!NayJM0ۄ
oäH8VK{I!lAַtշ]zmoMrpL Aw|$s=^ ']Xҿ{nMۤ]/Jjxpmom-뽽~I~oWIKoI'ִջ]IK[0[w\+۫t^ޟV?o}mߤz^C:u۽/ۮHZ~߿0_[oX{zu4-ޟm~MG?8t~_~}a{~{Unv%UտVU7K3ݿ}-+^σ_^%X~zM߿^ݿum%°oWn?I__mW5{okoxom'U}|[뿯O_VoW}Z]_zUzcU~_1zW\o^ޫBJ[oAݾpP۹NDtGDtGD|ת~[GUm/wp""#}I_NÃ7[[_x܂[VVY{锟ީҿkWpo*}Ŕա{E}7okO_NޯV{ჶk{}O{jv]D|]3qkw|`vr#RSNJ]+HիW_'>U}=iﭻXOENS?^A?^oT[|Do?[{[cPr(r!6ҪOuxAIW]~mq?n^w]/I_VoIzW7t}x[_Z}+oO]I=mwjz֟o֯]UKMi7Pjqm%a7ӥھWx`paA.nIAp,-]Jmkk^
V#a;U}nM0k$Јf D3a=2C9Cr(r(r(pNS9NS8":XVZl%ᴷT d09Ch1
L)(r,r(r(r(P@"""""""""=-[Ji&mj k$8"DÖ90ɎSpC9C9(r '!JC%ݮan Dph.'A@ Pw(s)¼(V5AXVA S4AC]$1@Yt(2HaFsh``Ca!`a<9(r(sB
B*e-T!
aB0O
qʂ*
DDDDDDDDDDyn5@e&E~PP(r*eZLPEɒ.DDDF
c`ܥ2b)Kr
""%JZGde7ꌔfG#GD4 G4"Eê9l#CHb᧾nDtBX)(DhE8ȏ>G
@75!A!
Aa8`E
a4]5FRtaD|D4hDDDqxA駦24 B
Tm$I7- I$>GD|>G#(3ˡ8*[" ¦ bp0G @
p
jI&)#"EP0菂o8":P3 A<pnIn"А"""D ^9OR,
fd(!(sPa!A $iIZ C22
[D? !lk^]Zo]!RK;:YN
aYAC!| aҭ`&L4kIꮁ4>6A4m ^N-{KIInI6<A0pOҿVׄvm'{IWu{zٝMIuo}O+[VnzN$K_6ۯWiRoaж?]:'~4?I_m_wVNKOI~+mo^mwzӵ7MǤ/O?Viom{]qqWaIA>_wצ:=צL[NWMvu]wUAoO{}&/a^ޝ~m
,%>z[wZ].}k0XKpߥݷ{u{KJVC~(}OݾޫK \o{{W{`Ҥ%upHeki+}ka+I~Ҹ7 o[:/o
woAr7PoTV
%^(/
w7u&9CD7
}AK8߯!Pr PMUW_w}֛b>$~=_mOnҿWoK~Koo=:wl?Wi7W۾_kM`nꮵwOoI_7]UmU{Uzn_vJ}'"HWM=_ۤ;iW[7Zo}MOV6Jl%mݺ}U5nxzV*åaa{0AVZtuv+Ka+t0Jھta Aj00I0L28D@.GY+bm+TҰ{m$(ri(!oTҵL6d7A
P9AfR$.<
Cr(r(r(r8苂nKۥo;Xet\CM>)"aSn=sS9C9CX0a+MjaA"8+ \6800
`K 6. AfaAa50DNPSH^LR H1D@4h]"a9C9C-9NEATCDsMAk
?/
8qw)ʲT-M!A98%r*
J#a
M9C9Cr({(r*DDDDDDDChDG
ZĴӄ)DtG̃DpBфF>G菑'>G#|aR-E`90:..4]#!А`DDhDDDDDFcɸ,.莈c*&G!DDDDD\FD]8eGGkYߣ4s#DtGeXB""L |GGIȀDÖLGdtuSh5`pёRB"",On@C0p GD&@!h BdHBА0 C4BC D/yn(tC0HFGy
]@22Dmp "`Ȁ C 4EE A
'tM4 "."0a:M824ʀֹ9PCSmiIһu膢@w4ȠjCD<tGDp0dᬊx0~II!tY
CH"pC:2'id08h p~+m"SE|?am9C9CG_m/n_]"""7BIoW=Nzq[v'];FۮKK'j]Z߆տzZ_ﻦw_[_~wmí-JkizOI{tm&[Kᄷ %m0]OjIma$`/u}IAmiIIu0A@D`hJ1.Eo$t
DhH`a{Ka&I݆%midrQ'h@4`;c9CACB"avAM6fgD^I9C9(rLPU
DDDDF0pa$ a \p2B"6$ZM`2)9CmY
a0Lp
)(r2MP`DDFM̑7UT@iз2%Re5B:
t[ #!c#9ܮ(5""%QB"1""B1#D]ѐt6g@"HdG8S0\嶔L"Et]FѴE#:#:#(@P"
0\">G莈 hlDDDD4""<5xD%ZHf^F$2#""!Z @`ADXDE">mF>G菗DtG荆Fr
T
AD)iƔjY0EtGt]8